Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in Key West / Florida Keys

OpenTable

Updated January 05, 2025

Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in Key West / Florida Keys? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Plaza Grill

4.9

4.9 (102)

$50 and over

Steakhouse

Marathon

About the restaurant

Plaza Grill offers a sophisticated, friendly, relaxing atmosphere, a cozy bar, comfortable chairs, attentive service, an award-winning wine list, and an unparalleled menu.
Get a selective glass of wine 25% off from 5:00 p.m. to 6:00 p.m.

Top review

MaryVIP

Dined 7 days ago

Food and service were both amazing! We will definitely be back.

Little Pearl

4.9

4.9 (2817)

$50 and over

Seafood

Key West

About the restaurant

We are OPEN 6 nights a week with 3 seating times
Monday-Saturday 5pm/7pm/9pm
Offering Chef’s Tasting Menu only. Unfortunately, our regular menu is unavailable at this time. Follow our website, Facebook, or IG for most current menu offerings... or just give us a call!
Please contact the restaurant with ALL dietary restrictions 24 hours before reservation for us to accommodate.
Thank you for your support during these unprecedented times! Looking forward to seeing you again!

Nestled in the heart of Old Town and away from the bustling downtown streets of Key West, Florida, sits an excellent spot for fresh local catch and innovative cuisine with a tropical twist.
Reservations are recommended!! Please call us for parties larger than 4 people.

Top review

Elena

Dined 1 day ago

Perhaps the best food in key west! Great service and the food was phenomenal!

Atlas Izakaya

4.9

4.9 (279)

$31 to $50

Japanese

Key West

About the restaurant

Atlas Izakaya is a chef-run restaurant focused on creating delicious, thought-provoking Japanese food. Meaning “stay-drink-place” in its native tongue, Izakaya is a word to describe the perfect spot to settle down with company as you dine together. Located in the heart of historic Key West steps from Duval Street, our restaurant provides a relaxed vibe to meet your palate. To live up to our name, we created a refined atmosphere that features an impressive open kitchen to complement the same great impression made by our menu. Complete with local seafood, fresh vegetable dishes, bao buns, dumplings, and much more, our offerings are the kind you’ll be craving in the weeks following your visit. If you’re in the mood for cozy comfort and whimsical Asian cuisine, join us at Atlas Izakaya.
Now offering Omakase Bar seating. Let the Chef cook for you at the limited 6 seat counter.
Call restaurant directly to book your 10 Course Shefu Menu.
Seatings at 530pm and 8pm. Call direct...
305-998-4189

Top review

Angela

Dined 1 day ago

The food rivals Nobu in every way. We took our waitress Allison’s recommendations and she curated the most incredible meal for us. The octopus and pork dumplings were favorites but everything we had was incredible! This is a must stop.

Discover more

Experience

Kokadama Plant Class

Cafe Sole - Key West

4.8

4.8 (3532)

$50 and over

French

Key West

About the restaurant

Café Solé has captured the hearts and palates of locals and visitors lucky enough to discover this culinary gem off the beaten path. By combining his French mastery of sauces with fresh locally caught seafood, John has created a menu unlike any on the island, where every dish is bursting with indescribable flavors. Mutton snapper in pesto and champagne, yellowtail in a beurre blanc of lobster or a rare hog snapper with red pepper zabaglione top a list of nightly specials. As for the classics, the Duck a L'Orange, Rack of Lamb with herb de Province and Lobster Bouillaise are as authentic as you will find this side of Paris. Chef Correa combines the best of both of his worlds, European and Caribbean to win the People's Choice and Best Entree awards at a recent Master Chefs Classic

Top review

KathleenVIP

Dined 1 day ago

What a wonderful dinner my husband and I had at Cafe Sole. Staff was nice and food was beautifully cooked. Highly recommend the Hogfish. Sounds horrible, but tastes delicious!

Discover more

Italian Food Company - Key Largo

4.8

4.8 (179)

$30 and under

Italian

Key Largo

About the restaurant

A slice of Italy in the Florida Keys! This approachable and genuine pizzeria/trattoria serves authentic Italian dishes in a warm and memorable atmosphere. Locals, families, couples, and groups flock to Italian Food Company for the food, service and attention to detail. Guests dine on imported, hand painted lava tables made by local artisans from the foothills of Mt. Etna, while overlooking our wine and beer garden. Hand painted murals depicting scenes from Sicily and the bay of Naples set the tone. Insta perfect picture spots come alive with a vintage Fiat 500 and the Italian Food Company Vino Van. If you have a love for all things Italy, you will come to adore this home away from home. Pizza Lovers beware - the Pizza is authentic Neapolitan, the real deal without the passport.

Top review

MarkVIP

Dined 2 days ago

Great place and food was excellent- don't pass up the pizza, some of the best ever, anywhhere! Service was prompt and friendly. One of the better italian places between Key Largo & Key West! Worth a stop by!

Discover more

4.8

4.8 (37)

$30 and under

Pizzeria

Key West

About the restaurant

Chef Marek is inspired by the pizzerias of New York, and he is bringing that inspiration to you to enjoy in the heart of the local scene in Key West, the White Street District. We also have a selection of unique TAPAS s to enjoy. So please join us for a special evening of relaxation with cold beer, fine wine, and friends old and new enjoying great pizza, unique small plates, and salads. A casual experience with gourmet food in a century old house that some say may have a ghost or two. Please make a reservation as space is limited and we want everyone to enjoy Key West's latest addition to the dining scene. Rock n roll fans step to the front with your munchies.

Top review

SusanVIP

Dined 1 day ago

Excellent sausage pizza! Service was outstanding!

Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar

4.7

4.7 (2078)

$31 to $50

Seafood

Marathon

About the restaurant

We offer casual waterfront indoor and outdoor dining at the islands oldest restaurant. Beautifully remodeled in 2007, our full service menu features Seafood, Sushi, Steaks, a full liquor bar and 32 Beers on tap. We were recently featured on Guy Fieris Diners, Drive-ins and Dives so make dinner reservations a day or two in advance if you can. We serve breakfast lunch and dinner and highly recommend making dinner reservations. We do not accept reservations until 4 pm but we are open all day everyday except Tuesday and Wednesday and welcome walk-ins anytime.

Top review

Andrea

Dined 1 day ago

The food was amazing as always and our server Andrea was awesome! She and the other staff made my daughter’s birthday dinner so special. We had a great time. Thanks so much!

Discover more

Popular dish

Hogfish

Popular dish

Toasted Coconut Key Lime Pie

Popular dish

Lobster Enchiladas

Italian Food Company - Islamorada

4.7

4.7 (294)

$30 and under

Italian

Islamorada

About the restaurant

Mangia in Islamorada! Co-owners Tony and Isis Wright have transformed the beloved and iconic building, previously home to Bentleys, into a slice of Italy in the Florida Keys. This approachable and genuine trattoria serves 5 star authentic Italian dishes in a warm and memorable atmosphere. Locals, families, couples, and groups flock to Italian Food Company for the food, service and attention to detail. Guests dine on imported, hand painted lava tables made by local artisans from the foothills of Mt. Etna, while overlooking various murals depicting scenes from Venice, Sicily and the Amalfi Coast. If you have a love for all things Italy, you will come to adore this home away from home - and it comes with the fun, fanfare, chefs and servers - imported from Italy with love.

Top review

Annette

Dined 5 days ago

We absolutely love the food here. The Italian Food company is our go to restaurant for Italian whenever we are in The Keys. Their Bolognese is the best I have ever had out. And the desserts are amazing as well. Good service, nice ambiance, all around a winner!

Discover more

Popular dish

Chicken Parmigiana

Azur

4.5

4.5 (2861)

$30 and under

Mediterranean

Key West

About the restaurant

Conveniently located in the heart of old Key West, AZUR Restaurant is the locals' and visitors' favorite for creative, Mediterranean cuisine. Whether you choose our shaded terrace or the cool blue dining room, please join us for a hearty breakfast featuring a few new twists, an al fresco lunch by the waterfall, or an intimate dinner with offerings including old favorites and new creations. AZUR is within walking distance of most guest houses and hotels, and also has free parking. For a completely unique dining experience in Old Town, AZUR is a must on your list of innovative-chef restaurants in Key West.

Top review

wilsonVIP

Dined 3 days ago

Fantastic beef and tuna carpaccio. My wife looks forward to going to this restaurant every time we visit key west

Discover more

Popular dish

Pulpo

Popular dish

Key Lime French Toast

Popular dish

Confit Duck Leg

Bob's on Margaret

4.5

4.5 (218)

$30 and under

Seafood

Key West

About the restaurant

Discover a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Key West

Welcome to our newest addition to the neighborhood
Our menu boasts an array of delectable dishes crafted with the finest ingredients, ensuring a symphony of
flavors. Whether you're craving seafood delights, savory classics, or innovative creations, our kitchen delivers
with finesse. Pair your meal with our curated selection of wines and cocktails

With both indoor and outdoor seating and private room (we also have a private entrance/exit), our restaurant invites you to savor your meal amidst the lively ambiance of dining room or under the starlit sky on our charming patio.

Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out with friends, our restaurant offers
the perfect backdrop for memorable moments.

Top review

WendyVIP

Dined 2 days ago

Fantastic Food! I had the fresh catch (Cobia) and my husband had the short rib stroganoff and they were both delicious. We also had the ceasar salad and grilled peach burrata salad, the ceasar was great, my only issue with the burrata was that I thought it would be warm and liquid inside, but it was chilled. That may just be how they prepare it. I would also add that our waitress, Eileena, was delightful.

Explore Diners' Choice best of Key West / Florida Keys

Explore more Diners' Choice lists

Seafood