Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Cape Cod and the Islands

OpenTable

Updated December 05, 2024

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Cape Cod and the Islands? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Leonessa

4.8

4.8 (1052)

$31 to $50

Italian

Yarmouth

About the restaurant

We warmly welcome you to Leonessa- an Italian-Inspired Kitchen & Bar on beautiful Route 6A in Yarmouth Port. Husband & Wife team, Chef Owner Diego Mota and Owner & General Manager Taylor Amara bring exceptional scratch made regional Italian cuisine and impeccable service to this iconic neighborhood. Combining the best of food and beverage of Italy along with the influences of its bordering neighbors coalesces into a dynamic, modern and elevated culinary experience. Chef Diego and Taylor's dream to pour their true love and passion for food, beverages, and hospitality is realized with every service. Reservations are for tables in each our four unique dining rooms while the Bar welcomes guests on a first come first serve basis. Please note that we do our level best to accommodate seating/area requests but they are not guaranteed. We also kindly ask that parties arrive together so that everyone can enjoy their time with us. Thank You.

Top review

RobertVIP

Dined 4 days ago

Outstanding food and outstanding service! Our choices included Arancini, Truffled Short Rib Risotto and Veal Milanese, all of which came out piping hot and were portioned generously. The kitchen is obviously skilled and knowledgeable, as all the food was savory and flavorful. The entire waitstaff (host, bar staff, servers and runners) was professional, attentive and friendly. The restaurant itself can be annoyingly loud at times, but that won't deter us from returning. Highly recommended. They won't disappoint.

Knots Landing Bar & Grill

4.5

4.5 (38)

$31 to $50

Italian

Chatham

About the restaurant

Welcome to Knots Landing: the New Home of New England Pizza Chatham!

The Malitas family are pleased to announce they've opened a new restaurant. Brother and Sister Philip and Sophia Malitas had the desire to own a restaurant for over 30 years. They opened New England Pizza in 1987 and have been serving the town of Chatham ever since.

With a love for the community and when the opportunity arose they purchased as well as totally renovated what is now known as Knots Landing Bar & Grill located at 1077 Main Street in Chatham. The dream of owning an upscale restaurant that is casual and family friendly has come true!

Please stop by Knots Landing lunch or dinner to try our amazing cuisine and don't forget to bring the family.

Top review

HeatherVIP

Dined on Nov 16, 2024

Knots is a hidden gem. Don’t let the giant New England Pizza sign out front distract you. Yes, they have yummy pizza but they also have fantastic burgers, seafood and pasta.

Buca's Tuscan Roadhouse

4.8

4.8 (598)

$31 to $50

Italian

Harwich Port

About the restaurant

Buca's Tuscan Roadhouse would like to transport you to a favorite trattoria - a little hole in the wall in Tuscany. So, join us, relax, have a glass of wine, a piece of cheese and let your journey begin!

Top review

Paul

Dined 5 days ago

I've been hearing about the place for a while and finally got there. Tomahawk veal parmesan was amazing. Prancing very good. Wild board meatball was excellent. Service was great as well.

Discover more

Milano's Italian Kitchen

4.6

4.6 (222)

$31 to $50

Italian

Harwich Port

About the restaurant

Our family welcomes you to join us at Milanos where we serve a variety of authentic Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality local ingredients.
If you can not find a time slot you are looking for for reservations please consider our new 22 seat bar/lounge area which is all first come first served opening at 4pm daily. Things can shift around so just come on in and we will do our best to seat you in the dining room if something opens up! If you need to Cancel your reservation, please do so on Open Table not by calling the restaurant.
Whether you are enjoying us for the first time or a faithful regular, we invite you to come experience our wonderful staff and menu favorites in their new home.

Top review

TomVIP

Dined 7 days ago

Good was amazing - we split a Caesar salad - one order of chicken parm and one of veal parm - both were North End worthy ! Can’t wait to go back… Lynne (our server) was great - ask for her

Alberto's Ristorante

4.7

4.7 (2851)

$31 to $50

Italian

Hyannis

About the restaurant

Alberto's Ristorante was established in 1984 at which time, Northern Italian cuisine and fresh homemade pasta were introduced to Cape Cod for the first time. Since then, we have continued this tradition of all fresh ingredients and in-house preparation of every course from the soups to the desserts.

Our reputation for casual elegance arises from our emphasis on decor, service, the pride we take in food preparation, and our affordability. Over the years, we have received rave reviews from food critics from the Cape Cod Times, The Boston Globe, The Boston Herald, Cape Cod Life Magazine, Fodor's, AAA, and New York Times critic James Beard for "...exquisite Northern Italian cuisine". Our lounge is the perfect setting for a before dinner cocktail, an after dinner espresso, or an even more casual meal. Call for lounge or bar seating (high tops only)

Top review

ralph

Dined 4 days ago

Celebrated our silver wedding anniversary at Alberto’s and our waiter made it special with great service complemented by excellent food.

Discover more

La Bella Vita Kitchen & Bar

4.6

4.6 (312)

$31 to $50

Italian

Orleans

About the restaurant

If you can't get a reservation we do reserve tables for walk-ins. We accept reservations for inside dining only.

Nestled in the heart of Orleans, Cape Cod, our restaurant offers a unique fusion of Italian-inspired cuisine. Our menu is carefully crafted to cater to a wide range of tastes, so whether you’re in the mood for Italian classics, steaks, fresh seafood, or American favorites, you’ll find something to delight your taste buds.
Our dishes are made with the freshest ingredients, including pasta and sauces, to create authentic and flavorful meals. Our seafood is sourced from local waters and is always fresh and delicious.
In addition to our Italian-inspired dishes, pizza, steaks, and seafood, we also offer a variety of American cuisine, including burgers, salads, and more. Our menu is designed to cater to all tastes, so there’s something for everyone. In the warmer months dine on our deck, outdoor patio, or sit and have a cocktail by the fire pits.

Top review

Dined on Dec 14, 2024

Very good service, good food, I have been back many times

Discover more

Popular dish

Short Rib Risotto

La Cucina Sul Mare

4.6

4.6 (1310)

$30 and under

Italian

Falmouth

About the restaurant

La Cucina Sul Mare in Falmouth serves up a blend of Italian and Mediterranean cuisine prepared by skilled chef and owner, Mark Cilfone. The interior of the eatery is warm and inviting with large hand painted murals, large picture windows that provide a view of busy Main Street and tin ceilings. La Cucina Sul Mare specializes in the preparation of Northern Italian dishes using old world cooking skills.

Be sure to try the saltimbocca, marsala, piccata, limone, parmigiana, lobster and asparagus ravioli with sauteed sea scallops, sweet potato encrusted scrod or the almond encrusted salmon. La Cucina Sul Mare serves up freshly made pasta and seafood dishes daily.

Top review

Katherine

Dined 4 days ago

Best bartender (and nattily dressed!), excellent food and service

Discover more

Nonno Pizza Cucina & Bar

4.7

4.7 (78)

$31 to $50

Italian

Hyannis

About the restaurant

Welcome to Nonno Pizza Cucina & Bar we look forward to serving you.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Nov 6, 2024

excellent service, great food, a great place to dine with the family

Colombo's Cafe

4.6

4.6 (271)

$30 and under

Italian

Barnstable

About the restaurant

The name “Colombo” is the Italian form of “Colomba” the latin word for “dove”, which is the “Bird of Peace”. It is in the spirit of peace that friends and family gather to celebrate the every day occurrences that touch our lives. Great food, drink and conversations are the cornerstones for the sharing of these convivial, day-to-day passions at our Italian restaurant.

Colombo’s Cafe & Pastries stands for the beloved concept born in Italy of the “gathering place”… truly a place that “welcomes everyone, every day… at any time” translating as “Benvenuti a tutti” in Italian, whereby the tried and true, centuries-old tradition of “all are welcome” prevails.

Top review

Chris

Dined 5 days ago

It was loud but the meal was great. I’m sure I’ll go back.

Villaggio Prime Bar and Grille

4.5

4.5 (907)

$31 to $50

Italian

Cotuit

About the restaurant

Delicious, authentic Italian food, prepared by a chef whose family's culinary history goes back four generations, and served in a charming 18th century Federal style building that is on the National Register of Historic Places: this is one restaurant that Cape Codders and vacationers alike should not miss!

Top review

cindy

Dined 3 days ago

Four of us dined at Villagio last night for the first time. We were seated right away in a lovely room. Our waiter was excellent-funny, smart, on top of everything. All of us were blown away by the food! We had bourbon meatballs, carpaccio, Caesar salad, cod Toscana, chicken piccata, chicken marsala. Everything was outstanding! We'll be back!

Explore Diners' Choice best of Cape Cod and the Islands

Explore more Diners' Choice lists