Best American Restaurants in Middletown

I can never say enough about our great experiences at this restaurant!! The atmosphere is fun and sweet, as is all the staff we have ever encountered here!!! The food is always amazing and it is the one place my daughter is a member of the “clean plate club”! We love this place and it is my daughter’s favorite restaurant! And though it was just the two of us our request when we made our reservation was honored and we got to sit at a tilt a whirl booth! The staff here constantly surpasses itself in making our meals here beyond our expectations! Thank you again! You are all awesome!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Wonderful experience! Server was great! Recommendations were on point, and even gave my wife a sample beer just because! Definitely recommend and will be back in the future!

Wild Game and Mushroom is always wonderful, and the food is consistently excellent so year round

If I could give service 10 stars I would. Lindsay was incredibly welcoming, hospitable, and accommodating. Her wit, personality and sense of humor was incredible from start to finish. Her service was top notch with multiple comments circling the table as “the best service.” Now onto food…..I wish I had 2 stomachs, or maybe 5. Our group enjoyed the she crab soup, pretzel and cheese appetizer, Brussels sprouts, Mac and cheese and wedge salads as a first course. We then moved onto dinner entrees; pan seared chicken, fish and chips, burger and lobster salad without a complaint. That spiraled us into ordering every dessert on the menu without a single regret. Sweet tooth satisfied, but I wouldn’t expect anything less from the sweetest place on earth. The Mon Frère Chardonnay was tastefully selected to pair well with the cuisine, and you can’t go wrong with the Signature Hershey’s Kisses Chocolate Martini with dessert. Again, my sweet tooth is very satisfied. Other resorts should take notes from The Hotel Hershey and the hospitality their hotel, restaurants and staff provide. 10/10 without a question.

I really like the River House both for the food and location as it is a great place to meet between Harrisburg and Lancaster. The food is always delicious. We had French Onion Soup, salads, and calamari because we were there for lunch. I have been there before for dinners and the only difference is that it is a sports bar so the noise level reflects that fact. I highly recommend River House for great food and friendly Staff.