Best Steakhouses in Montclair

We went to do a make up dinner from a bad experience at another restaurant. Let me tell you, EVERYTHING was great from drinks to food. Thanks for always coming through.

What can I say but they make you feel like you are family. Immediately upon walking in the door, they take care of you. The bar is amazing and the bartender knows how to make the most excellent drinks. The atmosphere is classy and beautiful. Appetizers, dinner and dessert are always satisfactory. We brought my mother here for her birthday and it'll be an experience she will never forget. Looking forward to more dinner dates at the Magic Lamp Inn

The Sycamore Inn Steakhouse is a fantastic dining destination that exceeded my expectations in nearly every aspect. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with friendly and attentive service. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel welcome and well taken care of, which really added to the overall experience. The food was the highlight of the evening. The steak was cooked to perfection – juicy, tender, and packed with flavor. Alongside it, the sides were equally impressive, offering fresh and delicious options that complemented the main dishes beautifully. It’s clear that the kitchen staff take pride in their work, as every plate that came out was crafted with care. The ambiance at Sycamore Inn is classic and cozy, with a historical charm that adds to the character of the space. However, I did notice that the noise level was a bit louder than usual, which made conversation slightly challenging at times. But the lively environment also brought a sense of energy and warmth to the restaurant. As for value, Sycamore Inn Steakhouse is priced reasonably for the quality of food and service provided. The experience felt worth every dollar, and I would gladly return for another memorable evening. Overall, the Sycamore Inn Steakhouse offers a wonderful dining experience that combines quality service, outstanding food, and a charming atmosphere. If you’re willing to overlook the slightly elevated noise level, it’s an ideal spot for a great night out!

The occasion was my wife birthday and my son and his wife anniversary. Our waitress was great she kept the drinks full. The food was awesome and my prime rib was just right. Even though my wife had the soup and salad bar they were both excellent. My son had his usual mesquite grilled steak with vegetables done perfectly. My daughter in law had halibut grill. She commented that the fIsh was done right. The evening end with ice cream for everyone. Thanks Cask n' Cleaver for wonderful dinner.

I had a wonderful time with my mother would forsure come back again