Best Italian Restaurants in Bethpage

The service is always impeccable! Everyone is very friendly, attentive and personable . The food is delicious, you will not be disappointed what so ever. The portions size are more than enough and food comes out nice and hot. The igloos are absolutely such a nice experience. The igloos are nicely decorated and are tempered controlled.

I can not begin to explain how special tonight was. I called ahead to specifically tell the manager it was my anniversary and wow did he go above and beyond to sure my wife and I had the best time. My servers were fantastic, the food was amazing, and I just left so happy. Well Done Casa Stellina!! Well done.

First time at Popei’s, we went for lunch. Service was very good, the ambiance is very casual, menu has an extensive selection. The garlic bread was a nice change from regular Italian bread. The seafood bisque was flavorful, the steamers were a little bland, the lobster tail was cooked perfectly. It comes with a stuffed clam which was flavorful. They give free refills for soft drinks.

from the time we entered this place, we were impressed. We entered into a large bar area, very well organized and with an awesome staff. We had a couple of drinks while we waited for our table. Once we arrived at the table we were greeted by our servers, Mike and Dominique. They were friendly and helpful. Their knowledge of the menu was impressive. We started with a wedge salad and a fried calamari/shrimp plates. The seafood was perfectly cooked and it tasted great. The salad, well is a salad, those were followed by a bucatini lobster and duck breast. They were delicious and the duck was perfectly cooked. That was accompanied by a creamed spinach, it was good, but I've had better. Finally we had the pistachio cheese cake, it was very good. On the down side, I thought that the tables were too close to each other

Nunzi’s was amazing from start to finish. We had a little hiccup with our reservation (an OpenTable issue), but Naz reached out and contacted me and situated the problem very efficiently. I was nervous at first because we were coming here for my birthday and I didn’t want to have any problems. We were very much accommodated. The staff were welcoming and attentive. Our waiter was amazing. He was very sweet and funny and gave great recommendations food wise. We ordered the meatballs and the Italian long hots for an appetizer. The meatballs were amazing the long hots are great if you like spicy. Dinner wise I can only speak on the chicken parm ala vodka is was 🤤 delicious. My friends loved their meals as well and the portions were great. We were so full afterwards. The ambience was lovely! Very comfortable and chill vibes. They had a nice like happy birthday sign at the table when we got there and sang happy birthday with our dessert. Even tho there’s a two Hour table time limit we did not feel rushed at all! Overall a great experience and they made my birthday special. Definitely worth the visit.