Best Fish Restaurants in Fishers Island

Went to Insignia for a belated Valentine's Day dinner with my wife and had a great experience. The service was five-star. Our waiter was beyond friendly and a consummate professional. We tried two different appetizers (stone cooked Wagyu and West coast oysters) which were incredible and served with amazing accompaniments. We both had different steak cuts for entrees which were cooked to perfection. Drinks were on point and the creme brulee and cappuccino were both among the best we have ever had. Do yourself a favor and reserve Insignia for your next special occasion!

The food was authentic and perfectly done, the service was excellent and the atmosphere was cozy yet lively. Chef (and owner) Aless added greatly to our experience and she is perfectly suited as a restaurateur. A fine French restaurant was sorely needed in the area. Highly recommend. We will definitely be back.

It was one of best meals i e had there. The appetizer salad , special for dinner and dessert all fabulous. Service was great! Never disappoints!!

Came for my wife’s Birthday and the place was Beautiful oh my goodness I mean perfect haven’t seen a restaurant this nice in a long time , the waitress and waiter were on point and made us hungry when he went over the menu . However I have to go back my steak was great but wish my veggies were a little more tasteful the Mash potatoes were really good but I must go back to Try something different

Great. Will probably go back. Food good. Ambiance good.