Best Pizza Bars in Coney Island

11 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria restaurant

1. Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria

4.8

Exceptional(66)

Price: Expensive

• Pizza Bar • Bensonhurst

Booked 2 times today

Il Colosseo Restaurant and Pizzeria, nestled in the vibrant Bensonhurst neighborhood of Brooklyn, has earned a reputation as a top destination for exquisite Vegan Italian cuisine. Diners consistently rave about the "authentically Italian" flavors and the "truly magnificent" dining experience. From the intimate and cozy atmosphere to the open kitchen where culinary magic unfolds, Il Colosseo offers a delightful vegan menu that stands out for its creativity and adherence to traditional Italian tastes. Patrons highlight dishes like the eggplant Parmesan and linguine with garlic and EVOO, praising them for being "perfectly seasoned" and "bursting with authentic flavors." Whether you're a local or just visiting, Il Colosseo promises a memorable vegan meal that captures the essence of Italian culinary artistry.

2. Gran Morsi

4.8

Exceptional(799)

Price: Expensive

• Pizza Bar • TriBeCa

Booked 15 times today

At Gran Morsi, located in the vibrant TriBeCa neighborhood of New York, every dish is a testament to the exceptional quality of Modern Tuscan cuisine. Known for its "elegant simplicity," this restaurant offers a menu that celebrates the rich flavors and authenticity of Italy, right in the heart of Manhattan. Patrons rave about experiences that "felt like I was in a Michelin star restaurant" due to the "fabulous" food and "very attentive service." Highlights such as the Meatballs that Beat Bobby Flay and the perfectly crafted Tagliatelle Bolognese leave diners both satisfied and enchanted. Gran Morsi not only serves outstanding cuisine but also creates memorable moments, making it a "neighborhood gem" that consistently exceeds expectations with its "delicious reliability."

A photo of The Frenchman’s Dough at Tin Building by Jean-Georges restaurant

3. The Frenchman’s Dough at Tin Building by Jean-Georges

4.6

Exceptional(59)

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • Financial District

Booked 9 times today

At the heart of New York's bustling Financial District, The Frenchman’s Dough at Tin Building by Jean-Georges offers a delightful fusion of Italian culinary tradition with a hint of French flair. Known for its "perfectly charred pizzas" and "freshly made pastas," this restaurant stands out as a beacon of Italian cuisine. Diners consistently rave about the "lemon pizza," described as "the best pizza in the entire world," and the service is frequently highlighted as "impeccable." One reviewer emphatically recommends, "Great meal - lemon pizza a must!" Whether it's the atmosphere, the expertly crafted dishes, or the attentive staff, The Frenchman’s Dough promises an unforgettable dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.

4. Serafina Tribeca

4.6

Exceptional(731)

Price: Expensive

• Pizza Bar • TriBeCa

Booked 26 times today

Serafina Tribeca, nestled in the vibrant TriBeCa neighborhood of New York, is a gem for authentic Pizzeria cuisine. With a beautiful setting that includes large windows perfect for any season, this restaurant offers more than just a meal—it offers an experience. Patrons rave about the Pizzeria, particularly the white pizza with arugula which has been described as "my favorite!" due to its "thin crust" and generous amount of "shredded cheese." Another guest celebrated the margarita pizza, highlighting its deliciousness alongside their tiramisu. Serafina Tribeca stands out not only for its top-notch Italian dishes but also for its consistent service and inviting ambiance, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors.

A photo of The Lineup Slice Shop restaurant

5. The Lineup Slice Shop

new

4.9

Exceptional(1)

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • Williamsburg

What’s better than pizza on a Saturday afternoon? NOTHING. But this isn’t your average slice. The Lineup Slice Shop is bringing together chefs from some of NYC’s top fine dining spots to toss dough, shred cheese, and get wild with toppings. Think beyond pepperoni—this is pizza reimagined! Flavors you’d never expect on slices that’ll blow your mind. One day only, it’s crispy crusts, gooey goodness, and a whole lotta fun. Whether you’re craving familiar flavors with a twist or ready to dive into some wildly creative creations, this is pizza like you’ve never tasted before. It’s the perfect combo of food nostalgia, creative flavor, and all-around good vibes. For just $30, you get UNLIMITED pizza—yes, as many slices as your heart desires. Grab your friends, and grab a table at the most creative pizza shop in town. You'll wanna grab these slices before they're gone!Hosted at The Test Brewery in Williamsburg Brooklyn12-4pmBeer and Wine available at additional cost

A photo of Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Eltingville restaurant

6. Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Eltingville

4.8

Exceptional(42)

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • Huguenot

Booked 6 times today

At Campania Coal Fired Pizza in Eltingville, Staten Island, the secret to their standout pizzeria cuisine is in the unique, smoky flavor that only a coal-fired oven can impart. This cooking method not only enhances the taste but ensures a texture that is unparalleled, as expressed by a satisfied diner: “The pizza was a perfect appetizer as long as you can stop yourself from eating the whole thing :)”. With options like the classic Margherita or the spicy Calabrese, every pizza is a testament to quality and authenticity. The rave reviews continue as patrons celebrate both the food and atmosphere, noting it as “always excellent” and perfect for any occasion, from casual dinners to special celebrations. This local gem truly captures the essence of a great pizzeria, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine slice of Italy in the heart of Staten Island.

A photo of Sofia's of Little Italy restaurant

7. Sofia's of Little Italy

4.1

Excellent(57)

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • Little Italy

Booked 6 times today

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Little Italy in New York City, Sofia's of Little Italy stands as a beacon of Italian culinary excellence. Renowned for its handmade pastas like lasagna and ravioli, and fresh-made pizzas, each dish at Sofia's offers a burst of authentic Italian flavor, described by one customer as “absolutely immaculate!” The atmosphere is as inviting as the food, with live music and a cozy setting perfect for any occasion, whether a romantic dinner or a lively gathering with friends. Praised for its exceptional service, one reviewer exclaimed, “Would recommend to the whole world!” With its commitment to quality and authenticity, Sofia's is a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine taste of Italy.

8. J's On The Bay

4.7

Exceptional(69)

Price: Expensive

• Pizza Bar • Shore Acres

Booked 2 times today

Nestled in the charming neighborhood of Shore Acres, Staten Island, J's on the Bay serves as a beacon for cocktail enthusiasts seeking a unique and sophisticated drinking experience. The restaurant's cocktail bar is renowned for its creative concoctions and meticulous attention to detail, a testament to Chef Joe Salimeni's dedication and innovation. Patrons rave about the "extraordinary cocktails" that perfectly complement the inventive cuisine. The ambiance of the bar, coupled with the exceptional service, ensures a memorable outing. Whether you're a local or just visiting, J's on the Bay promises a cocktail experience that's both refreshing and authentically delightful.

A photo of Il Porto Ristorante restaurant

9. Il Porto Ristorante

4.5

Awesome(125)

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • Clinton Hill

Welcome to Il Porto Ristorante, a gem nestled in Clinton Hill, Brooklyn, where Italy's culinary spirit thrives! Known for its authentic thin-crust pizzas from a wood-burning oven and a menu that dazzles with traditional recipes, Il Porto is a slice of Italy right in Brooklyn. Guests rave about the "phenomenal" flavors and "amazing" food that remind them of Italy, praising the "best thin crust pizzas" and "delicious pasta" that score a perfect 10/10. The ambiance, enriched with live music and a cozy patio, makes every dining experience special. As one reviewer puts it, Il Porto is "highly recommended" for its impeccable service, affordable prices, and the kind of Italian cuisine that makes diners come back time and again. Whether it's a family dinner, a romantic date, or a special occasion, Il Porto promises an unforgettable Italian feast.

10. Don Roberto’s

4.8

Exceptional(46)

Price: Moderate

• Pizza Bar • West Brighton

Booked 3 times today

Don Roberto’s serves up classic Italian & Italian American comfort food, reciepes passed down from generation to generation.Sister restaurant to DeLuca's Italian Restaurant-Best New Restaurant 2024-Cozy atmosphere, Trendy vibes-Signature Dishes; Famous Mamma's Meatballs, Lasagna, Chicken Parmigiana, Spicy Rigatoni Vodka

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

I
Igorvip
New York City •10 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Consistency good food and great service. Highly recommended
More info
The Frenchman’s Dough at Tin Building by Jean-GeorgesPrice: Moderate• Italian• Financial District
•
4.6
C
Cat
New York City •12 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Everything was delicious, service was impeccable. I love to see teamwork. The hostess, servers and busboy were very attentive, fast and knowledgeable. The noise level and ambiance was perfect. All the food came out in a quick succession — appetizers/ wine, the pizza/ more wine, main course, then dessert. We had a small table, and with each course, the staff was attentive and cleared our table, replaced plates and utensils and packed the food we couldn’t finish — then moved onto the next! The food was AMAZING. My favorite dish was the forest mushroom pizza, which I highly recommend. It has Truffle Roasted Mushrooms, Scallions, Fontina al Agosta. We also ordered: - polpette meatballs: Meatballs that Beat Bobby Flay! San Marzano Tomatoes. Three Per Order - cacio e pepe: Linguine, Parmigiana-Reggiano, Black Pepper. - penne bolognese - Chianti - sauvignon blanc - malbec - tiramisu: Savoiardi, Mascarpone, Amaretto, Cocoa. Wish we could have tried more on their menu. Everything we ordered was top notch. Highly recommend!
More info
Gran MorsiPrice: Expensive• Italian• TriBeCa
•
4.8
F
Francesca
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 16, 2024
My husband and I enjoyed our dinner at Serafina’s from the minute we walked in to when we left. Food was delicious and the service was spot on.
More info
Serafina TribecaPrice: Expensive• Italian• TriBeCa
•
4.6
O
Olivier
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 9, 2024
Amazing! So fun! Everything the lineup does is such a good time.
More info
The Lineup Slice ShopPrice: Moderate• Pizza Bar• Williamsburg
•
4.9
OT
OpenTable Dinervip
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined on Nov 3, 2024
Always have a great yummie time here and wonderful staff here :)
More info
Il Colosseo Restaurant And PizzeriaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Bensonhurst
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Coney Island

Pizza Bar

Best Pizza Bars in Coney Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

11 restaurants available nearby

1. Il Colosseo Restaurant And Pizzeria

2. Gran Morsi

3. The Frenchman’s Dough at Tin Building by Jean-Georges

4. Serafina Tribeca

5. The Lineup Slice Shop

6. Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Eltingville

7. Sofia's of Little Italy

8. J's On The Bay

9. Il Porto Ristorante

10. Don Roberto’s

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable