Best Historic Restaurants in Bayville

Sunday Brunch Plenty of selections Good variety Everything was good.

First time at OHK. They sat us in library which we didn’t expect but was nice until there was two large parties who sat in the library as well. Our intimate Valentines dinner suddenly became a group event. We asked to move and they accommodated moving us to a quiet room with only a few diners. Grateful for that, thank you OHK! Dinner was delicious, drinks great also. Would recommend for special occasion or when trying to impress your date!

Thyme is my go to restaurant for special occasions. I had the tuna tartare and lobster for my main course and Brussels sprouts. My husband had the delicious halibut with an amazing mushroom risotto. The apple cobbler and chocolate soufflé with gelato was also amazing.

Otherside Wine Bar never disappoints and last night was no exception. The Valentine’s Day prix fixe and wine pairing was out of this world. Everything was delicious and paired perfectly. This little peace of magic in Glen Cove will give the other restaurants a run for their money between the exquisite food and carefully curated wines. Cannot wait to go back!

We had a lovely early dinner on a Friday during restaurant week. Food was great as was the service. The venue is very nice with indoor seating and outdoor igloos that looked so cozy. They had a DJ that played great dance music beginning at 6pm. My only issue was that the Carriage House is on the Milleridge Inn property but it was difficult to find as it was located behind a huge tent and there were no prominent signs or lighting. That being said, I would definitely go back.