Best Historic Restaurants in Fire Island

amazing steak and sushi. I drove 45 minutes to come back to Insignia after i moved further west from Smithtown. don't miss it.

Have been here for two bridal showers but never had the pleasure of enjoying dinner before. It was delicious. The oysters were awesome we ordered another round. Also the fried zucchini blossoms were tasty. My husband and I both had the peppercorn sauce steak special and it was a lot of food! Drinks were strong and the bartender, Alex was wonderful. Very sweet and personable. Can’t wait to come back in the summer and sit outside.

We were a party of two, unsure of what to expect. Of course we decided to go the evening of the town St Paddy’s Day parade so all of the bars were excessively packed and loud. (Take that rating under consideration). We weren’t expecting a lot upon first sitting down, but boy were we pleasantly surprised. From the Caesar Salad to the filet mignon and everything in between (including the mashed potatoes and Brussel sprouts).. it was all delicious!

Consistent good quality & service Always a good time

Nice experience overall … server was very pleasant - they sang happy birthday to my sister for her birthday celebration…they even provided a portable heater when I was cold …will definitely go back !!!🤩