Restaurants near Neil Simon Theatre

I had an amazing experience here! The food was delicious, fresh, and beautifully presented. The staff was super friendly and attentive, specially Jose at the bar he made sure we had everything we needed. The atmosphere was cozy and welcoming, perfect for a relaxing meal. Can’t wait to come back

Highly recommend this restaurant! We were a party of five and had reservations; we arrived early but they sat us immediately. Extensive menu selection so we needed extra time to decide what to order. All the food arrived quickly, hot and served at the same time… most importantly, everything was DELICIOUS! One warning: huge portions of food so we couldn’t finish and didn’t order dessert. Our server Lena was on point, friendly, attentive and patient with us. We came on a rainy mid-December night… the place was busy and loud but Lena and other staff were helpful and didn’t miss a beat. We will definitely come back when we return to NYC.

Amazing food, service and vibe. Had the tuna tartare, spicy Caesar, steak frites, crab cake, Brussels and the opera cake. all 10/10. Will be back.

A lovely welcome from start to finish, first visit & the Carmine way was explained to avoid us over ordering our waitress Marianne was informative, friendly & warm. A wholesome portion of mozzarella topped garlic bread to share between two of us, the portion was huge & delicious - we were unable to finish the dish. The lasagne was to die for, tasty & hearty but again too big for the two of us & we can normally eat well. I can honestly say we have officially been Carmined, recommended by fellow Brits & I will be returning with my experience & recommending to fellow travellers, thank you Carmines x

We really enjoyed the live music, food, excellent service and colorful decor. It’s a must-do experience. We were very impressed with how organized the staff were and team communication was excellent in servicing patrons. It was our favorite place to dine on this trip