Best Neighborhood Gem Restaurants in Middleton

For about 35 years we have visited this restaurant and there have been many changes since it was Jimmy’s . But through the years what has not changed is the quality of food, service and atmosphere.

Absolutely LOVE Bonfyre! It never disappoints. We would dine there a lot more often if we lived closer.

The second year in a row me and my friends have gone to Lucille's for my birthday dinnner, and we will be back! Food and drinks are great and the decor is so cute.

From the fun holiday atmosphere and warm hospitality to the delicious, beautifully plated meal everything added to a memorable evening! Can’t wait to return.

We were exploring this venue for a small upcoming wedding dinner, and noticed how loyal the clientele seems to be from the other reviews. The food was outstanding, and the service perfect. We tried all the things on the menu that we thought might be our selections for our private event, and were not disappointed: 8oz filet mignon, seafood trio, feta stuffed chicken and the pasta with lemon cream sauce. I normally don’t order pasta at a fine dining place, but was checking it out for future vegetarian guests. I had shrimp on top, but it could well have been ordered with chicken or without meat altogether. (In fact we liked it better than the feta-stuffed chicken as a potential chicken dish. It was absolutely scrumptious, and definitely came out of a master chef’s kitchen. There was enough of each dish that we each took home leftovers, and I couldn’t wait to eat mine the next day. Still dreaming about whether I could possibly replicate this pasta recipe at home— I’m going to try!!! It was so good! But that’s not to undercut the other dishes whatsoever, which were our favorites, even better compared with food at some other local award-winning restaurants. The farmhouse is charming and looks just like the pictures. There is a disability ramp to the middle floor dining area and enclosed porch. But it you want the third floor, you’ll have to handle some stairs.