Best Historic Restaurants in Fishers Island
Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
5 restaurants available nearby
Booked 15 times today
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- LlindaNew York City •1 review5.0Dined 2 days agoGreat dining experience...ambience, food and staff!More infoOHK Bar & RestaurantPrice: Very Expensive• American• Huntington•4.6
- PpattydNew York City •26 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoWe recently had a birthday dinner party for nine. Service was excellent & food was very good. We have been to Milleridge many times over the years & would definitely recommend for any occasion.More infoMilleridge InnPrice: Expensive• American• Jericho•3.9
- EEricVIPNew York City •6 reviews5.0Dined on Feb 25, 2025everything was amazing, I highly recommend trying the painting night there, was a great night lots of laughs and great food!More infoRuta Oaxaca - WoodburyPrice: Moderate• Mexican• Woodbury•4.5
- BbarbaraVIPNew York City •7 reviews5.0Dined on Feb 23, 2025Food was excellent I highly recommend the chef is amazingMore infoThe Carriage HousePrice: Moderate• American• Jericho•4.7
- OOffirNew York State •1 review4.0Dined on Feb 15, 2025An unusual place that is historic and fun to go to. All out Hogwarts vibe. Rich wood etc. Chef is a CIA grad and his food reflects it. Everything seasoned properly and seasoned well with salt and butter. We had prix fix dinner which included a tasty and simpleamuse bouche, which was really an hors dourve. Appetizer course was perfectly cooked scallops and buretta. Salad course was the only thing that didn't live up to the rest of the meal. Two leaves of lettuce with cubed beets and a light citrus dressing. Entree was sea bass for us. Again everything was prepared meticulously with rich flavors. Lastly dessert was a classic creme brûlée and a deep dark chocolate cake. A real treat. We will definitely visit again.More infoMacArthur's Restaurant at The Historic Thayer HotelPrice: Very Expensive• American• West Point•3.9