Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Roslyn

We asked for seating up upstairs and glad we did! So much quieter up there. We could talk across the table without having to say “what?” all the time! The food was really good-our party had the artichoke salad (very different,very good), the short rib pappadelle with homemade noodles(melt in your mouth short ribs), the ricotta cavatelli (good, but over-garlicky, I was told) and chicken Milanese (so good). Spilt the peanut butter crunch cake— more a mousse than a cake imho, but a tasty end to a lovely meal. We ordered the California Merlot, the reasonably priced one(lol) and it opened up deliciously. Oh, I cannot forget the service: from the young man at valet parking, the women hostess & coat check, waiter and bus boys— all lovely and thoughtful. It was a delightful evening!

Amazing as always! Food was impeccable and service is no other. It’s always a pleasure to dine at the Polo Lounge!

ordered from the price fixe menu.. $40.95 for glass of wine, appetizer, entree and dessert. Had the caesar salad (excellent), salmon and brussell sprouts (also excellent) and raspberry sorbet. Bread basket with hummus was also good, just should have been put on the table sooner. Service was good. Beautiful fireplace, but not overly decorated for Christmas. just some poinsiettas. I recommend and would go back.

Karen is a wonderful server. My Macadamia Crusted Halibut was delicious.

We had a great experience. Food , atmosphere, everything was great.