Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in North Babylon

Tellers never disappoints!! We had the perfect table on a cold, snowy night next to the fireplace in the side bar room…our favorite spot! Our experience this trip was that much better with Chelsea as our server! Great suggestions for our meal & she was spot on! (*filet Oskar style!). Can’t wait to come back!!

Excellent food and service. We were celebrating our anniversary which the waitress acknowledged by bringing us champagne. Everything we ordered was delicious and our waitress Griselda was fantastic.

Exceptional, just exceptional! The restaurant was packed but we didn’t wait long to be seated. Our waitress was wonderful- kind and knowledgeable. The food was some of the best I’ve ever had- each dish was better than the last! The artichokes as an app- what can I even say?! I’m not a fan of artichokes but figured I’d try something different as my husband enjoys them. Thank goodness we ordered them; they were citrusy and crunchy from the breadcrumb topping. Just perfect! The spaghetti with lobster was outrageous; luscious, creamy, with a tiny bit of zing towards the end. The lamb chops were cooked to perfection- my husband would have licked the plate if he could. While I had no room for dessert, we ordered the pistachio gelato and it was the most pleasantly intense pistachio flavor- absolutely divine!!!

I always love coming here for dinner! The food is consistently amazing, and the ambiance is so pleasant, making it the perfect spot for a relaxing meal. The service is always top-notch. A special shoutout to the restaurant manager, Nico—he’s awesome! His attention to detail and friendly demeanor really make the experience stand out. Highly recommend this place!

Amazing experience for my fiancés birthday! Complimentary champagne to start! Food was delicious and the drinks were strong. All desserts are homemade and sound delish but the key lime pie was our #1!