Best Restaurants for Anniversaries in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Love this place! We are from out of town and this is the second time we have eaten here. Both times the food has been delicious and the service has been above and beyond! Very nice people. And you can’t beat the view!!

Outstanding neighborhood gem Italian restaurant with a long history of excellent food and service.

Amazing food! Focaccia and Eva pizza were excellent. Also, their salads are so fresh a nd tasty as a starter or side! Our friends had gnocchi with their Buona Forchetta sauce and would recommend. My kids also love, love, love their fresh fettuccini noodle with butter. Simple but delicious! 😆 Such a warm, cozy experience and great service!

The experience here was great. The atmosphere was lively and very inviting. Food was delicious but a bit pricey. Overall very satisfied with STK. Would recommend highly as long as you are ready for bill over $200 easy.

Delicious food and wine, amazing cocktails, great service, cozy ambiance and close to home. What more can you ask for? Chef Giorgio did ravioli filled with slow braised short rips as a special. My husband was in heaven. We shared a Burrata with arugula and cherry tomatoes first. Always a winner. I'm not a big pizza fan. Only exception are Giorgio's! I had the special one with arugula, prosciutto and burrata on top (not on the menu!) and it's mouth watering, with a perfect crunch and very fresh ingredients. Now it's no longer a square and served on a board , like in Roma, but a pie and I enjoyed it a lot. Enzo is a savvy waiter, recommended us good choices and gave us excellent service. We'll be back soon !