Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Bayville

Our 'Galentines brunch' today was wonderful. Sara, our server gave her attention, all the staff in fact were wonderful. Our Japanese seafood appetizers, lobster hash and desserts were each terrific. Sitting in the atrium was beautifulmas it's always been. A complete step above experience!

even though it was valentine’s day at 9:30 pm, the crew held it together considering there was a mildly unruly crowd of people at the entrance waiting to check in/be called to be seated. my reservation was at 9:30 and we only waited about 25 minutes (i’ve waited longer for worse) sat us promptly in excellent seats and immediately had the wine list ready for us to order. the calm demeanor of the staff was very comforting considering how absolutely bustling it was. it was my first experience here and i can say i’m very impressed by the service and the selections at the center ‘market table’*. countless choices of italian meats, cheeses, vegetables.. etc. although i couldn’t see any bowls for the soup, i was more than satisfied with the rest of the choices available. every meat in styles you would never think of were waltzed around the entire seating area, of which my date and i sampled all. the lamb steak was seasoned and cooked perfectly, you can absolutely taste the flavors of the meat itself without it being overpowered by seasoning, probably our joint favorite. although the filet mignon was a bit dry and overdone, it was small potatoes compared to every other selection of meat that emerged upon our table. each member of staff was very polite once again with the preponderance of meat selections. a side of mashed potatoes and two sides of pão de queijo were delivered with no request. overall i’ll give it an 8.1/10. guaranteed to make any date night into and extravagant event.

Everything was well-thought of from the rose at the door to the heart-shaped napkins on the table. The band was amazing, and the food was great this place is a 10/10

Otherside Wine Bar never disappoints and last night was no exception. The Valentine’s Day prix fixe and wine pairing was out of this world. Everything was delicious and paired perfectly. This little peace of magic in Glen Cove will give the other restaurants a run for their money between the exquisite food and carefully curated wines. Cannot wait to go back!

The food and service were wonderful. We were never rushed through the meal