Best Date Night Restaurants in Muskoka

Excellent seasonal special night out. Quality menu and ambiance/decor. The Pan Seared Scallops were perfection and the Prime Rib a good portion and medium rare. Enjoyed the “Harvest” seasonal gin cocktail and the Pistachio Cheesecake was neither too sweet nor heavy.

My family and I had a great brunch today (December 22, 2024) at the Cliffside restaurant at the Muskoka Bay Resort. The food was delicious. It was proportioned, cooked, presented and priced right. My daughter loved the Lemon Meringue French Toast (but wished she didn't fill up first on their delicious hot chocolate). We'll definitely be back (probably for a skate on their great rink first).

This was the second time we've invited guests from out of town to join us at The Common Stove. Always a fantastic dinner of incredible flavors and plating creativity. My bride and I shared two entree's: The Halibut and the Duck rolled into pasta shells. Everything was divine without exaggeration. Service with Mel was impeccable: friendly, knowledgeable, and with us at just the right times without hovering. Even the sticky toffee pudding to complete the experience was enjoyed by all four of us..... we joked about asking for a straw for the sauce! We'll be back of course because we love it and there is always more to the menu to enjoy!

Food was excellent at Vintages.The roasted ontario rack of lamb is the best I had ever eaten.

Small restaurant. Great food. Tables were a little close where you can hear multiple conversations. Hoped that restaurant would have overlooked the lake but doesn't.