Best Casual Restaurants in Tarpon Springs

For the first time, we made reservations for Christmas. The special meal offerings were amazing! (Regular menu items were also available). Our server was Robyn, and she was an absolute joy!! I can imagine it may be hard for some to work on Christmas/Hanakkah. She never stopped smiling, the mood was festive, and we had a great time. We may make this our new annual tradition. Thank you for making our visit excellent!

Food was great, service was very good. Excited to come back

John, our server was on it ! Prompt, friendly, efficient and accommodating. The atmosphere was inviting and comfortable. The greeting staff were organized and welcoming. Then the food…. Wine in a chiller and ice water= perfect Bread service= crunchy soft baguette, garlic herb butter and a bit of cheese with the wine= superb Hogfish and Chilean sea bass= perfectly prepared, tasty sauce, well cooked rice= exceptional White chocolate bread pudding and vanilla ice cream= very delicious ending. Thank you Mystic Fish ! Merry 🎄 Christmas

A top chef serving only the finest food. Going there for 17 years and hard to believe it gets better and better each time. Massimo never disappoints with his Italian and continental master pieces. His servers have been there from day one and that says loads about this romantic gem.

Captn Jack's has great food and even better service! We love the seafood and pies. Great atmosphere!