Best Casual Restaurants in Siesta Key

We were seated promptly and Lucas was great. We were helped with some dietary restrictions to create perfect meals. The meal was not rushed and we could linger after. Parking was very easy

Wanting to have outdoor seating for lunch brought us to Libby’s. Unique cocktails (purple cactus), delicious food (Crabby Patty was crispy & scrumptious) & comes with a side salad, and knowledgeable staff make it worthwhile.

Loved sitting at the bar. Alyssa was amazing, entertaining and so helpful with decisions on your amazing menu. We will be back! So many more delicious looking and sounding foods to try.

Our go-to place for special occasions (last night Valentines) so we’re very fond of this quaint restaurant in downtown Sarasota except last night it was so busy that some items seemed to have slipped through the cracks. The food is always great however last night wasn’t as great. The service was excellent for us but we noticed other tables were not as fortunate. The prices seemed to have been adjusted for the Valentine’s menu (adjusted meaning RAISED), for we each had a meal, (Grouper / Pork Oso-busco) nothing fancy) a glass of wine and shared a dessert with one complimentary basket of bread (NOT even a house salad) and the bill was $175! A bit pricey if you’d ask me.

Food was excellent. We had a table outside and the evening was exceptional. It was my birthday and other than the slight delay in getting us seated, we enjoyed our meal tremendously. Waitstaff was excellent and we couldn’t have been more pleased with the food, the atmosphere & the overall experience…this being our first time visiting Clayton’s.