Best Authentic Restaurants in Suffern

My husband and I went to That Supper Club on Valentine's Day and had a fantastic time! Everything was just perfect. The food, ambiance, attention to detail, and sense of feeling taken care of and right at home at the same time was unmatched. The staff is outstanding! So warm and welcoming, while taking us on a journey of the courses is a wonderful experience. The courses were absolutely delicious and perfectly spaced out. We love not feeling rushed and we never felt that way at The Supper Club, which allowed us to truly enjoy our night out. It really is a beautiful experience and we cannot say enough about it. We love that the menu changes periodically which will allow us to have a whole other experience the next time we go, which we definitely will!

Sushi is always amazingly fresh and delicious. The drinks were spot on and the service was great.

We had the plater of dips, octopus, turlu, Greek salad, baked beans, sardines, and chicken souvlaki. In the end we had a plater of Greek homemade dessert. Everything was delicious and perfectly made. The staff were very friendly and polite. Excellent experience.

We had a delicious, cozy birthday lunch here! It was everything we were looking for--delicious food in a cozy environment to catch up. *BYOB* but we just opted for some sparkling water to start. All their options sounded delicious. We finally decided on Zucchine Flan for starters (fresh and tasty) and dined on Cavatelli and Gnocchi for our mains. Must try their desserts too! Espresso Affogato and Crostata. YUMMM. Neighborhood gem. Highly recommend! Staff was very courteous, knowledgeable, and polite. Owner stopped by to say hello as well :) (they offer a Business Lunch menu--will need to go back to try. A more affordable option to try other menu options!)