Best Authentic Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Amazing staff and food that’s to die for. I love italian food and this is by FAR my favorite Italian restaurant! Taste remains the same each visit. I leave satisfied and happy each time!!!🩷 I hope they continue to thrive and stay in business for a long time. I CANNOT RAVE ENOUGH ABOUT THE COMPLEMENTARY BREAD 😋😋 -The pasta straws are super adorable and innovative !

Food, drinks, ambience was all great! Loved it and highly recommend

Amazing food, wonderful service. My whole family raved about it, too. What a pleasant surprise. My mom and sister said the pesto was the best they have ever had, and we’re Italian-American and hard to impress! I personally really appreciated the vegan and gluten-free options, which were all excellent. The server, even the bussers, everyone was a pro. Pleasant, helpful, and really added to our experience. So glad I found this place and brought my family!!

We enjoyed a Christmas Eve feast at Solare. We got there early, and were directed to their lounge area until our table was ready. Enjoyed a perfect Prosecco and Chianti and chatted with a few folks sitting at the bar. This place always feels like family, the team at Solare is always helpful and engaging.. We took a table outside and had a fantastic meal. I especially liked the Lamb Porterhouse. So good. The seasoning was very unique. The Owner, Randy, even stopped by. He really seemed to care about how our meal was, and offered a few suggestions. Our server Francois, helped us get the perfect wine, and was extremely attentive, even though this was one of their busiest nights of the year. Thanks to all the folks at Solare for making this a great evening.

The small plates are entirely original, owing more to Asian and other fusion than to Spanish tapas. The cocktails were original and enhanced the meal. Ambience was great