Best Authentic Restaurants in Peapack-Gladstone

First of all, food was outstanding. The steaks were terrific, the sides were great, the portions were very generous. (We went the Friday after Thanksgiving and now we have steakhouse leftovers in addition to turkey.) The service from Steven was also great - very knowledgeable, personable, but not intrusive. One caveat - the inside dining is very noisy. No rugs or tablecloths, and a high ceiling make for a noisy experience. The ambiance is fine. The food is pretty expensive - although I think it was worth it. I won't be eating here every week, but for special occasions, it's OK.

Food is consistently excellent and very flavorful. Staff is very warm and welcoming.

We had a wonder first time at tap and bitter. It was a quiet Sunday but the staff checked in on us throughout our dinner. We always had water and didn’t feel rushed and they gave us time in between courses to relax and enjoy each other company

Food was excellent. Service was great. We had an early reservation and was seated at a table that was a little cramped. We felt like our meal was being rushed to make sure they had that table for the next seating. Would have liked to go a little slower and enjoy my meal. Would try to make a later reservation next time to avoid being rushed and to sit at a more comfortable table.

Its in the details. Food was excellent. Portion’s generous. Service is the issue. Staff was pleasant but inattentive and under educated. Server did not know what dressing came with chopped salad and did not know what osso bucco ravioli was. We waited at least 20 minutes after completing our main course to get a desert menu. The glass top table was soaked with condensation from our beverage glasses, tablecloth or coasters please. The ravioli was very good, but a teaspoon more filling would have made it excellent. The tiramisu was different and possibly the best we have ever had, including that in Rome. A bit more attention to details elevates this restaurant to one of the absolute best.