Best Authentic Restaurants in Fishers Island

66 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Blackstone Steakhouse restaurant

1. Blackstone Steakhouse

4.8

Exceptional(6284)

Price: Very Expensive

• Steakhouse • Melville

Booked 62 times today

Blackstone Steakhouse features a dazzling array of cuisine, from prime dry aged steaks to amazing sushi and fresh seafood. We also have our own authentic sushi chef, a fabulous raw bar and award winning wine list. Dine or enjoy cocktails al fresco in our outdoor lounge featuring ambient lighting, lush landscaping and ultra-comfortable oversize booths and seating. Our menu is truly unique, combining tantalizing steakhouse classics with amazing sushi and seafood creations. In addition to serving the finest prime dry-aged and Kobe beef, we have our own authentic sushi chef and a fabulous sushi and raw seafood bar. Plus, our sommelier can help you select the perfect wine from our 850 bottle, award-winning wine list to complement your meal.

A photo of Casa Stellina Ristorante restaurant

2. Casa Stellina Ristorante

4.6

Exceptional(194)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Farmingdale

Booked 19 times today

Nestled in the heart of Farmingdale, our newest culinary endeavor emerges as a vibrant extension of our passion for Italian cuisine. Introducing Casa Stellina, a spinoff that radiates the same warmth and authenticity as its predecessor, Stellina Ristorante.Inspired by the bustling energy of Farmingdale, our vision is to create a culinary haven where locals and visitors alike can experience the essence of Italian hospitality. As a nod to our roots, we invite you to embark on a journey reminiscent of the rustic charm and timeless flavors found in the heart of Italy.

3. 317 Main Street

4.7

Exceptional(1659)

Price: Moderate

• Gastro Pub • Farmingdale

Booked 15 times today

Chef Eric LeVine uniquely weaves local cuisine into an American Grill, setting himself and “317 Main Street” apart from the many restaurant choices on Long Island. The two time “Chopped” Champion, Chef Eric LeVine is bringing his talents to Farmingdale, a growing destination spot for great food, distinctive cocktails and unbeatable entertainment. For a one of a kind experience, reserve a seat at the Chef’s Table. Watch Chef Eric as he entertains you with his creativity, humor and passion for fresh local food. Craft Cocktails are a favorite at “317 Main Street” where trendy meets fresh. Served up by the best trained mixologists, our cocktails will leave you impressed and quenched.

A photo of Ruta Oaxaca - Woodbury restaurant

4. Ruta Oaxaca - Woodbury

4.7

Exceptional(142)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican • Woodbury

Booked 2 times today

Our Story The goal – to guarantee a wonderful meal with authentic cuisine and fabulous margaritas, serve over 50 artisanal and ancestral mezcals, and over 100 different types of tequila brands in a vibrant unique atmosphere that boasts excellent service. Ruta Oaxaca Mexican Cuisine opened in Astoria in 2021 with such a wonderful and successful home run that a second location opened in Patchogue in March 2022. Ruta Oaxaca means “Road to Oaxaca,” a historic state in the southern part of Mexico. Mr. Castillo and his Partners are keenly focused on honoring Oaxacan culinary traditions, whose fame is derived in great part from its many varieties of moles. By legend, these ancient recipes are more than sauces, they are the very focus of the meal. Ruta Oaxaca proudly features four moles, each prepared using the Oaxacan mole recipes that have made the cuisine world famous. Visit us at our locations in Astoria 929-349-1228 Patchogue 631-569-2233 Woodbury 516-515-9620 Brooklyn 718-576-1507

5. RARE650

4.7

Exceptional(5534)

Price: Very Expensive

• Steakhouse • Syosset

Booked 42 times today

Rare 650's design boasts a chic main dinning room, dramatic floor to ceiling wine room and an energetic bar and lounge. Dine or enjoy cocktails in the stunning glass conservatory featuring ambient lighting, tropical landscaping and ultra comfortable booths and seating. The menu is truly unique, combining tantalizing steakhouse classics with amazing sushi and fresh seafood creations. In addition to serving the finest prime dry-aged steaks, Rare650 has an authentic sushi chef and a fabulous sushi and raw seafood bar. Plus, the sommelier can help you select the perfect wine from an 850 bottle, award-winning wine list to compliment your meal.

A photo of Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar restaurant

6. Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar

4.8

Exceptional(391)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Farmingdale

Booked 3 times today

A rich tradition of quality in food comes to Farmingdale Village with Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar. Come sample our authentic Italian cuisine. Whether dining on our delicious food menu or having a drink from our diverse beverage menu at the bar, Vespa is here for your enjoyment.

A photo of Sawasdee Thai Elevated restaurant

7. Sawasdee Thai Elevated

4.6

Exceptional(412)

Price: Moderate

• Thai • Plainview

Booked 1 time today

We have a 10 minute grace period. Please call us if you are running later than 10 minutes after your reservation. Groups 5 or more subject to 20% service charge.Tables will be reserved for 1 hour and 30 minutes for parties up to 4; 1 hour and 45 minutes for parties of up to 6; and 2 hours for parties of 7+.Sawasdee (sah-wah-DEE) is spoken both as a greeting and a farewell. Sawasdee Thai Elevated brings authentic Thai cuisine to Long Island in a setting that is warm, inviting and stylish. Our founders began their journey in the heart of Thailand. Owner John Conrad met his wife Walailak in Thailand, where she was born and raised. John lived and worked in Thailand for 5 yrs and adored the experience. He looked for a way to bring an authentic Thai cultural experience back to America.That’s how Sawasdee was born: as a restaurant that combines authentic Thai cuisine with modern dining. Thai food is all about marrying complexity with harmony, Sawasdee aims to continue that tradition.

A photo of Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale restaurant

8. Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale

4.4

Awesome(1435)

Price: Moderate

• Mexican / Southwestern • Farmingdale

Booked 8 times today

Caracara serves authentic, upscale Mexican food in a comfortable setting. Couples, families and singles will feel at home in our dining room or tequila lounge. We are open seven days a week for lunch and dinner serving table-side guacamole, great margaritas, mojitos and sangria. Specials are offered daily and happy hour is Monday-Friday, 4pm-6pm in the tequila lounge. Our tequila list includes 70 premium tequilas. Menu features traditional entrees including Tamales, Iron Skillet Tacos and Enchiladas as well as our own innovative items such as Pollo Relleno. Special prix fixe dinner menu for $29.95 Monday-Wednesday. (Starting September 2021) Tuesday is Taco Tuesday in Tequila lounge 4-6pm. Comfortable bar booths available as well as outdoor seating in season.Lunch Menu served Monday - Friday 12n-3pm; Dinner Menu Served Monday - Friday after 3pm and Saturday and Sunday from 12 noon.

A photo of Cirella's Restaurant & Bar restaurant

9. Cirella's Restaurant & Bar

4.7

Exceptional(1529)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Melville

Booked 13 times today

25 years at this "bustling" Melville hub for both "business meetings" and " family celebrations," "gracious" hosts make folks "feel welcome" as they dig into "large portions" of "delicious" Continental and Northern Italian Favorites. The first to turn a veal chop into veal parmigiana and the first to offer sushi at an Italian Bistro "crudo" Italian Sashimi. Our Sushi Chef ranked 3rd best sushi on Long Island. The Cirella family owns and operates restaurants in some very unique locations. While shopping, don't forget to look for our sister location Gastronemy located inside Saks 5th Ave in the Walt Whitman mall. Each Restaurant is managed by a family member which means you can always find a cirella around "our family serving yours" has become our slogan over the years. Become "al la familia" ONE OF THE FAMILY*Open table reservations count towards all tables in the restaurant. Accommodations requested through open table reservations are not guaranteed. Please call for guarantees.

A photo of Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano restaurant

10. Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano

4.6

Exceptional(289)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Farmingdale

Booked 6 times today

We stay true to Italy's culinary standards to retain the natural freshness and flavors of our dishes, which makes us one of the ONLY restaurants in the US to never incorporate artificial flavorings, colorings, or preservatives, nor do we use corn syrups in any of our beverages. We take pride in guaranteeing that none of our offerings contain GMO fruits, vegetables, or processed seed oils. Our olive oil, frying oil, flour, and sauce are all imported from Italy, while our meat, seafood and produce are sourced locally. We strive to replicate the culinary experiences that we find when we visit the Amalfi Coast. Our hometown, Vico Equense, is referred to as the “Gateway to the Amalfi Coast” and the "Food Capital of Italy". Directly across from Monte Vesuvio, Vico is rich with the same soil as the San Marzano area. We aim to share the cherished memories cooking with Nonna. It was here that we learned the significance of the food we savor and endeavored to preserve her treasured

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

D
Dave
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Everything was phenomenal, but for reasons that are unclear we were seated out of the main dining room at noon on a Monday. Very minor issue (because it was near a chilly atrium in December) that in no way detracted from superb food and service.
More info
Blackstone SteakhousePrice: Very Expensive• Steakhouse• Melville
•
4.8
T
traci
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Amazing food and service. Drinks are a little pricey but delicious! 100% will return soon!
More info
Ruta Oaxaca - WoodburyPrice: Moderate• Mexican• Woodbury
•
4.7
P
Pamela
New York City •11 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Paul and his staff were amazing. Very accommodating, polite and personable. Delicious Greek food cooked to perfection. Made us feel very comfortable.
More info
Mythos Authentic Greek CuisinePrice: Expensive• Greek• Bayside
•
4.7
K
Kimberly
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
This place is an absolute must— over and over again! I went with friends for a few apps… not realizing we should have brought a greater appetite! The service was outstanding- our waiter was attentive, knowledgeable and made great recommendations. The food was truly memorable, especially the fried artichokes, which were masterfully accompanied by an incredible lemon aioli, and the grilled octopus, which was tender and full of flavor. The bufalo burrata was fresh, creamy and just delicious— and the Romain style pizza was perfection. This will be a regular on the restaurant rotation, for its service and incredible menu— that I’ll be looking forward to trying one of everything!
More info
Casa Stellina RistorantePrice: Expensive• Italian• Farmingdale
•
4.6
OT
OpenTable Diner
San Francisco Bay Area •2 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 11, 2024
We went at an off hour (2 PM) so got stuck between shifts. We lost our waiter halfway through the service. On the plus side we were able to speak with the chef. All of the food was fresh and inventive and locally sourced when possible (Shinnecock Bay scallops). This is a gastropub so expect elevated food in casual but cozy surroundings.
More info
317 Main StreetPrice: Moderate• Gastro Pub• Farmingdale
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Fishers Island

Best Authentic Restaurants in Fishers Island

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

66 restaurants available nearby

1. Blackstone Steakhouse

2. Casa Stellina Ristorante

3. 317 Main Street

4. Ruta Oaxaca - Woodbury

5. RARE650

6. Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar

7. Sawasdee Thai Elevated

8. Caracara Mexican Grill - Farmingdale

9. Cirella's Restaurant & Bar

10. Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable