Best Authentic Restaurants in East Indy

Amazing restaurant with a fantastic atmosphere. The live piano during dinner adds such a special touch. The food is truly authentic Italian, beautifully presented and absolutely delicious—definitely a 6-star experience! I highly recommend visiting!!!

Casa Santa is $$ for Mexican cuisine but this is a fine dining experience, with everything a couple of steps above the others. Good cocktails (mezcal old fashioned, special valentines drink that was not too sweet, margaritas), table made guacamole was extra special. fantastic twists on classics. Service always excellent.

INItaly definitely brings a taste of Italy to small town Pendleton. The pizza was delicious and the servers were delightful. They only offer a 10 inch pizza but it was plenty of food for two. This restaurant is not your normal Indiana pizza but definitely worth a visit. We will go back!

Wife and I were immediately greeted by the owners as we walked in the door. Had reservations, but decided to sit at the bar as they were the ones tending. Service, drinks, and every last item we ordered was absolutely outstanding. We made a reservation to bring family while eating dessert. Our new favorite spot.