Diners' Choice: Best Overall restaurants in West Sussex

OpenTable

Updated January 05, 2025

Looking for the best overall restaurants in West Sussex? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

The Cat Inn

4.9

4.9 (1909)

£25 and under

Contemporary British

East Grinstead

About the restaurant

The Cat Inn is a 16th century free house set in the picturesque village of West Hoathly, a hilltop village set in the heart of the Sussex countryside. It is in within easy distance from the towns of East Grinstead and Haywards Heath and only 25 minutes from Gatwick Airport.

The Pub with its oak beams and two inglenook fireplaces proffers a warm and cosy atmosphere in the winter, whilst our terrace is perfect to enjoy a drink and food in the summer months. Being a free house we pride ourselves in the quality of our real ale, and concentrate on local breweries, such as Harvey's of Lewes and other micro breweries. Our food is cooked to order, using fresh, seasonal and where possible locally sourced ingredients. Our menus change on a regular basis and we also offer a small selection of seasonal specials on a daily basis.

We welcome children over the age of 7. Dogs are welcome in the "pub" area of the Cat, they are not permitted in the dining room

Top review

AndrewVIP

Dined 6 days ago

Great meal out with friends in a lovely welcoming pub with a good kitchen

The Fig Tree Restaurant- Hurstpierpoint

4.9

4.9 (795)

£41 and over

English

Haywards Heath

About the restaurant

Found in the heart of Hurstpierpoint, the picturesque village nestled closely to the rolling hills of the South Downs National Park, The Fig Tree is an elegant dining venue offering fresh and seasonal dishes.

Tempt your tastebuds and indulge with our ever-changing tasting menu. Offering seasonal dishes made with the finest local produce, it’s time to tempt your tastebuds.

Top review

Angelica

Dined 5 days ago

The food was absolutely delicious, I love the experience with the six course menu, We love to try the new menus regularly because every time we are more and more surprised It is a good restaurant for lovers of good cuisine my only suggestion is to change the bread, I would like a soft and fresh bread Thanks to the chef

Masala City

4.8

4.8 (461)

£25 and under

Indian

Chichester

About the restaurant

Experience the best curry in West Sussex
Come and experience the warm welcome of Chichester Curry House “Masala City” and enjoy an authentic Indian experience in a fantastic location full of character.
The emphasis at Chichester’s Masala City Indian Restaurant is on producing authentic Indian food, using the best quality ingredients and where possible locally sourced produce.
Chichester Indian Masala City serves an extensive array of authentic meals, which are freshly prepared using only the best and finest ingredients for both dine in and takeaway (serving Chichester).
Driven by an ambitious and passionate management team. We aim to make your dining experience memorable by providing a warm atmosphere where you can enjoy our great quality Indian food that is complemented by the excellent standard of service

Top review

Gio

Dined on Jan 6, 2025

After much research and debate we decided o celebrate our 24th Anniversary dinner at Masala City. Booking was easy, even when (at short notice) we needed to delay our arrival for by an hour. We were warmly welcomed when we arrived and given a choice as to where we felt most comfortable to be seated. We ordered drinks and whilst deciding on our meal they along with the papadums and sauces were served. We ordered the prawn starter and mixed starter. Both were delicious. I had a tandoori mixed grill (my favourite) and my wife had chicken tikka masala. This was the best Indian meal we have ever shared! The food was served in good time and looked very appetising. It tasted even better and because the portions were so generous we asked for a "to go bag" . The experience was pricey, but worth every penny. We will definitely return.

Discover more

4.7

4.7 (61)

£26 to £40

English

Chichester

About the restaurant

Eat, drink and relax. Our restaurant rewards food and wine lovers with a unique warm and friendly environment to enjoy time with partners, friends or family. Our restaurant is one of the few restaurants in Chichester in which you can indulge in rural British cuisine. Utilising the gardens, the Potager Restaurant uses fresh, home-grown produce creating a true ‘farm-to-fork’, or as well like to call it ‘Potager-to-plate’, ethos. Our Chefs and trained front of house staff will treat you with fantastic service, friendly smiles and great food. Characterful, contemporary oak-beamed restaurant with views over open countryside. Award winning Cuisine, 2 AA Rosettes for food excellence

Top review

Susan

Dined on Jan 5, 2025

Delicious Sunday lunch with generous portions and really tasty gravy! Excellent friendly and attentive service and lovely views of the gardens.

Discover more

The Safari Pizza co, pizzeria and wine bar

4.8

4.8 (293)

£25 and under

Pizzeria

Haywards Heath

About the restaurant

Wood fired pizzeria and wine bar on the Broadway in Haywards Heath. Serving a selection of fantastic pizzas and wine.

Top review

Sarah

Dined 4 days ago

We had a brilliant evening at safari pizza. Our waitress was very attentive and funny.

Terra Restaurant at Tottington

4.7

4.7 (170)

£41 and over

Farm-to-table

Henfield

About the restaurant

Terra restaurant is located at Tottington Manor which is beautifully situated in the South Downs National Park with hillside and farmland views, yet it is just 10 minutes from the A23 at Pyecombe and the A27 at Shoreham.

With a menu showcasing the best of local ingredients cooked fresh each day by our team of chefs, you can enjoy dinner in the restaurant, or outside on our decking, or in winter time, choose our more relaxed fire side Olive Restaurant.

In addition we have a number of private dining options available from 6 to 95.

Our South Downs Suite is completely separate with its own private garden, stretch tent and bar and is ideal for family celebrations, parties and of course Weddings. Our events team are always available to provide tours and discuss your plans, call them on 01903 815757 or email events@tottingtonmanor.co.uk

Tottington Manor also has 12 bedrooms comprising of 5 unique superior rooms , 5 comfort double rooms and 2 comfort single rooms.

Top review

Louise

Dined 7 days ago

This was my second visit to Tottington Manor as a follow-up to a function I attended late last year, and my first visit to Terra. On arrival we were warmly greeted by the very charming Louis, Tottington'a General Manager, who was charming and is clearly a real asset to Tottington. We were seated quickly and left to peruse the menu and our orders were taken soon thereafter although we were not rushed. My mother and I both chose to skip the starters and go straight for a main course. Mum had lamb while I had the chicken dish and both were exceptional - beautifully presented and cooked and seasoned to perfection. We then opted for the mini bite size desserts which were a taste sensation, if a tad small. All in all this was a really pleasing visit where we enjoyed superb food and excellent yet very discreet service which I very much appreciated. Indeed, I am already planning my next visit with a very discerning friend who I am hoping will be similarly impressed. My sincere thanks to Louis and the wider team, and a very big pat on the back to all.

Discover more

Experience

Valentines Day 2025

The Star & Garter

4.7

4.7 (179)

£26 to £40

Gastro Pub

Singleton

About the restaurant

Located in the heart of the Goodwood Estate and surrounded by the South Downs National Park, The Star & Garter in East Dean offers a delicious selection of freshly cooked, local and seasonal food in a charming dining space with red brick and oak beams. Just a mile down the hill from Goodwood Race Course we are 12 minutes drive from Chichester. Open for breakfast, lunch and dinner we try to source our ingredients as locally and as seasonally as possible. Whether you are at a Goodwood Event or walking, cycling or just out for a drive and fancy a decent meal at reasonable prices, we like to think we are one of the best around. We have a great courtyard and garden space which can seat up to 100 people. Freshly ground coffee is available all day. With a mixture of local people and tourists there's always a warm welcome here.

Top review

Shirley

Dined 5 days ago

Really lovely pub lunch on a cold January day. Log burner burning nicely. Lovely home cooked food and friendly pub owners. Recommend a drop in.

The farmers

4.4

4.4 (421)

£25 and under

British

Haywards Heath

About the restaurant

We are pleased to be recognised as a family run pub with attentive friendly staff, something that repeatedly comes up on our reviews. Our aim is to provide good quality freshly produced food and at reasonable prices.

We are delighted our customers love the warm welcoming ambience of the pub and enjoy the traditional and slightly quirky decor.

The Farmer’s Sunday lunch always offers a choice of three meats, fresh vegetables and goose fat roast potatoes. We also offer a homemade vegetarian option and can cater for gluten free and other requirements, just ask us.

Top review

Pamela

Dined on Dec 19, 2024

Three of us requiring a gluten free lunch we’re delighted to find a good choice on a well marked menu. The sticky toffee sweets were particularly enjoyed. Great to have a good varied choice of main courses unlike other pubs in the area. The service was friendly and meals good value. We will book again and recommend to our Airbnb guests

That's Amore Italian Restaurant

4.6

4.6 (191)

£25 and under

Italian

Haywards Heath

About the restaurant

A beautiful Italian restaurant in the heart of Lindfield set back from the high street.
That’s Amore brings the flavours of the Italian kitchen to your table.

Order for Collection or book your table with us today.

Top review

Steven

Dined on Jan 4, 2025

The food was outstanding, we were two couples and we all had something different and every dish was perfect. The service we received was excellent and staff were very accommodating. The only slightly negative thing I would say is the ambiance was not brilliant, more of a cafe feel than a restaurant. Having said this I would highly recommend this restaurant, we will definitely being going back. One last thing, the location is excellent right next door to the Bent Arms and on the high street of the beautiful village of Lindfield.

Explore Diners' Choice best of West Sussex

Explore more Diners' Choice lists