Best Steakhouses in Reynoldsburg

Everything at Butcher & Rose exceeded my expectations. My fiancé and I went to celebrate our 4th anniversary and upon arriving at the table there was a cute notecard saying happy anniversary. From the person who was refilling our waters, to our actual waiter and even back up waitress everyone was so extremely friendly and knowledgeable about the menu as this was our first time there and had valuable recommendations. The ambiance was nice and felt the price for everything we ordered and the experience was worth the money. I plan to come back again.

Always a Great experience with food and service by the staff. We were celebrating a birthday requested seating in the bar we had a wonderful night. The side dishes were excellent and the dessert was delicious. We will be back.

Our server, Joe Meyers, was nothing short of phenomenal. His attention to detail and genuine enthusiasm elevated our night to the next level. Joe’s knowledge of the menu was impressive—he guided us through the best cuts of steak and paired them perfectly with sides and wine recommendations. But what truly set him apart was his personality. He was personable, engaging, and even shared his passion for ice cream, sparking a delightful conversation that added a unique touch to our dinner. If you visit Jeff Ruby’s, ask for Joe Meyers—you won’t regret it. He’s the kind of server who turns a great meal into an extraordinary experience. We’ll definitely be back!

Another great meal & experience at Hyde Park. We've tried all the other options & HP continues to be our favorite for both quality of food & service. We even gave Jeff Ruby 3 tries to unseat HP, but the food quality just wasn't there for us. Happy to be back!

I am sad I do not recall the waitresses name we had last night. She was very attentive. It was my birthday and she served us our drinks and gave us time to enjoy each other. I had the Branzino and it did not disappoint. My husband had the loaded baked potato and a ribeye. The meat was perfect! Can’t wait to dine at The Avenue again.