Best Steakhouses in East Setauket

Midweek 50/50 special for porterhouse and wine may be the best deal on Long Island. Food was great as was service and ambience

amazing steak and sushi. I drove 45 minutes to come back to Insignia after i moved further west from Smithtown. don't miss it.

Our server was absolutely outstanding, courteous, knowledgeable, polite. Perfect night to go on a date night. It was quiet, relaxing food as always was spectacular.

Benoit, Giovanni, and the rest of the team at Rothmann's are incredible. It's the little things that they do right that make the rest of the experience truly exceptional. My wife and I went there to celebrate our 13th wedding anniversary (24 years together) and the food was exceptional but the service is what sets Rothmann's apart. This is our new favorite steakhouse and will come here to celebrate special occasions and milestones.

Overall, we had a very nice dining experience. Our waiter was excellent. He patiently moved our table to the tea of the restaurant when we requested. He was extremely attentive to our every need during dinner. The wedge salad was delicious. The sides: French fries, creamed spinach and mushrooms were all very good. The tomahawk steak was cooked to perfection and very tasty. The porterhouse for two was cooked to temperature, however it was much more fatty than expected. We were disappointed in the overall steak. Everything else was wonderful. I’d give it another try!