Best Steak Restaurants in Croton Falls

Everything was perfect. The service was 5 stars, steak cooked to perfection. And drink were good too.

The best! Consistently excellent; food, cocktails, service, ambience. Menu has a great mix of steak, seafood, pastas.. all with a Mediterranean flair. The calamari appetizer is a MUST, very different than the fried calamari you can get anywhere else. The baklava cheesecake is such a great representation of the menu as a whole: cheesecake (a steakhouse classic) but creatively made with a phyllo dough crust - the combination you never knew you needed until now. The owner, Mentor, is very involved in the business and really hustles throughout service. He’s remembered us every time since our very first visit. Most recently saving us our favorite spots at the bar on Valentine’s Day which I felt exceptionally grateful for considering that holiday can be stressful with reservations. Will be back again and again!

Went for Valentine’s Day, got a great table because we went earlier in the night at 5 PM. Service was attentive, professional, and kind. Asked them to fix a temperature issue with my wife’s filet mignon and they immediately fired it up for resolution. Ambience was great. Food & drinks were 4-4.5/5.

We love the Saddle River Inn…it is our favorite restaurant to celebrate our birthday, anniversaries and special times. The food is always expertly prepared with amazing flavor. The service is flawless and the atmosphere superb.

We started with freshly prepared calamari and a good bottle of wine. Then 3 different types of steak coupled with mashed potatoes French fries and asparagus. Creme brûlée and raspberry sorbet. More than enough food and leftovers to enjoy the next day. The service was exceptional and the steaks were cooked to perfection. Definitely will return