11 Best Southern American Restaurants In Sanibel

A photo of JWB Grill Fort Myers Beach restaurant

1. JWB Grill Fort Myers Beach

4.7

Exceptional(502)

Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Fort Myers Beach

Booked 37 times today

JWB Grill is quintessential cool overlooking the Gulf of Mexico. Step into JWB Grill and escape the everyday with spectacular off-the-boat seafood, prime steaks, curated wines, and signature Margaritaville cocktails. The experience is always fresh and cool with our seasonal menu that absolutely delights the senses. Our beachside paradise features live entertainment, bar with a vibe, and welcomes all (resort guests and those visiting just for dinner) with laid-back luxury and a hint of sophistication. Reservations are strongly encouraged. Plan ahead - our entire resort is cash-less.

A photo of Rae's Real Italian restaurant

2. Rae's Real Italian

4.6

Exceptional(296)

Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Fort Myers

Booked 13 times today

Rae's Real Italian, nestled in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, offers a delightful fusion of American charm and Italian culinary excellence. Known for its "authentic and fresh" flavors, this beachfront gem captivates diners with its breathtaking views and "phenomenal" service. While the name may suggest Italian, Rae's expertly crafts American cuisine with a flair, making it a must-visit for those seeking quality and authenticity. Guests rave about the "superb" dining experience, emphasizing the "great food" and "wonderful service" that make every meal memorable. Whether savoring the sunset or indulging in a special occasion, Rae's promises an unforgettable American dining adventure.

A photo of Gather - Cape Coral restaurant

3. Gather - Cape Coral

4.6

Exceptional(156)

Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Cape Coral

Booked 14 times today

Gather - Cape Coral is a culinary gem nestled in Tarpon Point Marina, offering a delightful blend of Fusion and Eclectic cuisine that enchants the palate. The restaurant skillfully combines traditional and Mediterranean flavors with classic dishes, creating an international twist that leaves diners eager for more. Guests rave about the "exceptional service and outstanding food," with dishes like grilled octopus and short ribs on truffle pasta frequently praised for their exquisite taste. The ambiance, enhanced by stunning waterfront views, invites patrons to "forget where you are and travel with your senses." Gather's inventive menu and craft cocktails make it a must-visit for any food enthusiast.

4. The Green Flash

4.6

Exceptional(1029)

Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Captiva Island

Booked 76 times today

The Green Flash in Captiva Island is renowned for its exquisite seafood cuisine, delivering a fresh and authentic dining experience that seafood lovers rave about. Known for using market-fresh fish, the restaurant's seafood offerings, like the "Caribbean lobster tail" and "coconut crusted red snapper," are consistently praised for their delightful flavors. Diners frequently highlight the "outstanding" seafood sampler, which showcases the restaurant's commitment to quality and freshness. With stunning waterfront views that enhance the dining experience, The Green Flash offers not just a meal, but an unforgettable culinary journey, making it a must-visit for anyone on Captiva Island.

A photo of Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro restaurant

5. Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro

4.0

Excellent(497)

Price: Moderate

• Southern american • Cape Coral

Booked 13 times today

At Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro, located in the stunning Westin Cape Coral, diners are treated to authentic American cuisine with a flair for quality and taste. Overlooking the beautiful Tarpon Point Marina, this gem offers a rich menu featuring prime rib every Saturday at five o'clock, perfectly complementing their full bar selection. Guests rave about the "fabulous food, superb service, great atmosphere," and the "delicious drinks." The restaurant's commitment to accommodating dietary needs and providing attentive service ensures a dining experience that is both memorable and satisfying. Enjoy the vibrant flavors of America in a picturesque waterfront setting!

A photo of Fathoms Restaurant & Bar restaurant

6. Fathoms Restaurant & Bar

4.7

Exceptional(100)

Price: Moderate

• Southern american • Cape Coral

Booked 23 times today

Fathoms Restaurant & Bar in Cape Coral offers an authentic American dining experience that delights locals and visitors alike. Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional service, Fathoms showcases a menu filled with American classics, including hand-crafted pizzas and delicious entrees. Guests rave about the "outstanding service and food," highlighting the Prime Rib Monday as a must-try. The scenic views overlooking the Cape Harbour Marina add to the charm, making it perfect for enjoying their famed cocktail happy hour. Whether dining indoors or at the lively tiki bar, Fathoms promises a memorable American culinary journey with a friendly, welcoming vibe.

7. Old Captiva House

4.4

Awesome(2118)

Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Captiva Island

Booked 32 times today

Old Captiva House, nestled within the scenic 'Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa on Captiva Island, offers an exceptional American dining experience that stands out with its "New Florida" flair. Guests rave about the "delicious bouillabaisse and blackened snapper" and the "grouper with lobster risotto," highlighting the restaurant's knack for elevating classic American dishes with fresh, local ingredients. The charming atmosphere and "friendly, professional service" make every visit memorable, while the breathtaking Gulf-front views provide the perfect backdrop for America's most romantic sunset. With a reputation for "5-star service all the way around," Old Captiva House is a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic American cuisine with a delightful twist.

8. Next Door

4.9

Exceptional(177)

Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Cape Coral

Booked 14 times today

Nestled in the heart of Cape Coral, Next Door shines as a beacon of exceptional Fusion/Eclectic cuisine. This charming restaurant expertly marries authentic traditional recipes with a modern twist, creating a unique dining experience that is both innovative and comforting. Guests rave about the "refreshing spin on scratch pasta," with fresh dishes crafted daily in their open kitchen, showcasing the artistry of their chefs. From the exquisite wagyu carpaccio to the succulent scallops, every dish is a testament to their commitment to quality and creativity. With a thoughtfully curated wine list and a cozy atmosphere, Next Door is a must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable culinary adventure.

9. The Shipyard

4.6

Exceptional(34)

Price: Expensive

• Southern american • Captiva Island

Booked 18 times today

The Shipyard on Captiva Island is quickly becoming a seafood haven with its fresh and authentic offerings. Diners rave about the "delicious crab cakes" and the "real deal" fried grouper sandwich, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality and taste. Nestled in the renowned 'Tween Waters Resort & Spa, The Shipyard combines a stunning Gulf view with impeccable service, making it a must-visit spot for seafood enthusiasts. The atmosphere is vibrant, with live music enhancing the dining experience, and the friendly staff ensure a warm welcome. For those seeking outstanding seafood in a lively setting, The Shipyard is the place to be.

10. Jack's

4.1

Excellent(205)

Price: Moderate

• Southern american • Fort Myers Beach

Welcome to Jack's Restaurant at Pink Shell Resort. Kickstart your morning with a savory or sweet breakfast and gorgeous waterfront views—now included for every resort guest with a room reservation! Jack’s also welcomes guests not staying at Pink Shell Resort to start their morning with a delicious breakfast. Featuring a buffet with a fresh omelet station, waffles, eggs, oatmeal, fruit, breakfast beverages and more, get ready to fuel up for a day

Best Southern American Restaurants in Sanibel

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

11 restaurants available nearby

1. JWB Grill Fort Myers Beach

2. Rae's Real Italian

3. Gather - Cape Coral

4. The Green Flash

5. Marker 92 Waterfront Bar & Bistro

6. Fathoms Restaurant & Bar

7. Old Captiva House

8. Next Door

9. The Shipyard

10. Jack's

Explore OpenTable