5 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Middletown

5 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Semolina Restaurant restaurant

1. Semolina Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(3181)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Red Bank

Booked 36 times today

Semolina Restaurant in Red Bank is a gem of Contemporary Italian cuisine, praised for its inventive use of local, fresh ingredients that elevate traditional Italian dishes to new heights. The farm-to-table approach ensures every dish bursts with flavor and authenticity, with "pasta dishes that are particularly fantastic," as diners rave. Guests highlight the "outstanding" service and the cozy, welcoming BYO atmosphere that complements the dining experience. The menu, which rotates seasonally, keeps patrons excited with each visit. Semolina's commitment to quality and creativity makes it a standout choice for anyone eager to indulge in exceptional Contemporary Italian dining.

A photo of Limoncello at Piazza di Roma restaurant

2. Limoncello at Piazza di Roma

4.8

Exceptional(26)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Matawan

Booked 2 times today

At Limoncello at Piazza di Roma, the Seafood cuisine is nothing short of spectacular, offering an authentic taste of the sea with every dish. Nestled in the picturesque surroundings of Matawan, Aberdeen Township, this delightful restaurant transports diners straight to the heart of Italy. Reviews rave about the "outstanding Sea Bass" and the "expertly cooked scallops piccata," highlighting the impeccable quality and freshness of the Seafood. Diners are enveloped in a warm ambience that complements the exquisite flavors, making it an unforgettable dining experience. If you're seeking a true taste of the sea, Limoncello is a must-visit destination.

A photo of Blu Grotto at Monmouth Park restaurant

3. Blu Grotto at Monmouth Park

4.5

Awesome(1133)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Long Branch

Blu Grotto at Monmouth Park in Oceanport is a shining example of Contemporary Italian cuisine, offering diners an exquisite fusion of modern adaptations and regional Italian classics. Chef James Corona’s commitment to using the freshest and locally grown ingredients ensures that every dish bursts with authentic flavors and quality. Guests rave about the "delicious entrees" and "generous glasses of great wine" paired with the "beautiful atmosphere." The restaurant's ambiance is described as "fabulous," making it a perfect spot for special occasions. With attentive staff and a creative menu that never disappoints, Blu Grotto promises an unforgettable dining experience.

A photo of Gargiulos Tinton Falls restaurant

4. Gargiulos Tinton Falls

4.8

Exceptional(1230)

Price: Expensive

• Sicilian • Tinton Falls

Booked 20 times today

Gargiulos Tinton Falls is a beacon of Contemporary Italian cuisine, seamlessly blending tradition with modern flair. This family-owned gem, steeped in over 50 years of culinary heritage, offers diners in Tinton Falls, NJ, a genuine taste of Italy without the need for a transcontinental journey. Guests rave about the "fantastic food," which consistently delivers delightful surprises from appetizers to desserts. The stuffed artichoke and scallop appetizers are especially praised as "phenomenal" by patrons. The ambiance is inviting, with an old-world charm that complements the exquisite dishes. Experience their "excellent service" and "authentic" flavors that make every meal memorable and satisfying.

A photo of Cafe Luna of Old Bridge restaurant

5. Cafe Luna of Old Bridge

4.8

Exceptional(532)

Price: Moderate

• Sicilian • Old Bridge

Booked 28 times today

After over 20 years of serving fine Italian cuisine in New York City, we are proud to announce our newest location in Old Bridge New Jersey. Join us under the stars in our romantic dining area, lounge or upscale bar, serving our authentic Sicilian Cuisine, delectable desserts and extensive wine list. We pride ourselves on serving the finest ingredients in every dish. Whether you’re having an intimate dinner or seeking to host a special event, happy hour, or other occasion, Café Luna of Oldbridge will provide a dining experience that is out of this world!

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Middletown

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

5 restaurants available nearby

1. Semolina Restaurant

2. Limoncello at Piazza di Roma

3. Blu Grotto at Monmouth Park

4. Gargiulos Tinton Falls

5. Cafe Luna of Old Bridge

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable