Best Seafood Restaurants in West Islip

17 restaurants available nearby

1. The Lakehouse

4.7

Exceptional(3144)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Bay Shore

Booked 9 times today

The Lakehouse in Bay Shore, NY, is a contemporary American dining gem that consistently delights its patrons. Celebrated for its "always delicious" meals and exceptional service, this dockside treasure offers more than just a meal; it provides an experience. With its stunning waterfront views and cozy ambiance complemented by multiple fireplaces, it's no wonder reviewers rave about the quality and creativity of the dishes. Favorites like the "sensational" baked oysters and "magnificent" truffle risotto showcase the authentic and expertly crafted menu. Additionally, the ability to arrive by boat adds a unique touch to the dining experience, making The Lakehouse a must-visit for those seeking a truly remarkable Contemporary American meal.

A photo of Tres Palms Coastal Dining restaurant

2. Tres Palms Coastal Dining

4.5

Awesome(650)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Babylon

Booked 1 time today

At Tres Palms Coastal Dining in Babylon, the essence of American cuisine is celebrated with a commitment to free-range, natural, and sustainable ingredients, making each dish not only delicious but also healthy. This establishment stands out for its dedication to using locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that every bite is of the highest quality and freshness. Patrons frequently rave about their dining experiences, noting the "delicious and very filling" meals and "first in class" service. The relaxed, beachy atmosphere complements the superb food, with one reviewer declaring, "I feel like I am on vacation every time I eat here." Whether it’s the fresh oysters, clams, or the innovative Lobster Eggs Benedict, Tres Palms consistently impresses, making it a must-visit spot for authentic American dining on Long Island.

3. Captain Bill's

4.7

Exceptional(2017)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Bay Shore

Booked 3 times today

At Captain Bill's in Bay Shore, the essence of American cuisine is celebrated with flair and finesse. Renowned for its waterfront charm and a menu that showcases the best of local seafood and prime aged steaks, Captain Bill's represents American dining at its finest. Guests rave about the "delicious and fresh seafood" and "perfectly seasoned prime rib," highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity. The ambiance, described as "beautiful and kind of romantic," complements the excellent service, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether it's enjoying a sunset over the Great South Bay or indulging in a Sunday brunch buffet with unlimited Bloody Marys and Mimosas, Captain Bill's is a culinary gem that consistently impresses, making it a must-visit destination for lovers of genuine American cuisine.

A photo of White Castle - Deer Park restaurant

4. White Castle - Deer Park

4.8

Exceptional(11)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Deer Park

White Castle - Deer Park has reinvented fine dining with a twist, making it the go-to destination in Deer Park for exceptional seafood and more. Known for its unique take on seafood cuisine, this restaurant offers a creative menu highlighted by the "Love Clutch Collection," a must-try for seafood enthusiasts. Patrons rave about the freshness and quality, with comments like "Great Food. Always fresh!" underscoring the culinary experience. On Valentine's Day, the atmosphere turns especially magical, promising a dining experience filled with delightful dishes and charming wordplay that adds to the festive mood. Whether it's the quality of the sliders or the impeccable service, White Castle - Deer Park ensures every visit is memorable.

A photo of Red Lobster - Deer Park restaurant

5. Red Lobster - Deer Park

4.6

Exceptional(2)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Deer Park

Elevate your day at Red Lobster, where fun meets fancy and every meal is a celebration. Whether you’re marking a special occasion or treating yourself or your crew, Red Lobster is the perfect place to enjoy all your seafood favorites. Dive into our signature shrimp, wild caught lobster and crab, and more. Plus, a variety of fish and popular non-seafood items like our Cajun Chicken Linguini Alfredo. Looking for a showstopper? Create Your Own Ultimate Feast or select a Live Maine Lobster straight from the tank. Or explore our Daily Deals with a different special available each weekday at a price you’ll love. Toast the day with Signature Cocktails including Lobster Punch and Main Deck Margarita Flights to make any moment feel festive. You won’t want to miss our newest menu items or special promotions like Lobsterfest and Crabfest. Reserve online today. Group Dining, To Go, or Catering options. For parties of 11+, please call.

A photo of Red Lobster - Copiague restaurant

6. Red Lobster - Copiague

4.3

Awesome(32)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Amityville

A photo of Tellers: An American Chophouse restaurant

7. Tellers: An American Chophouse

4.8

Exceptional(5572)

Price: Very Expensive

• Seafood • Islip

Booked 30 times today

Tellers: An American Chophouse in Islip isn't just renowned for its steaks but also shines in its seafood offerings, making it a top destination for seafood lovers. Patrons rave about the fresh and "amazing" raw seafood platters and the "delicious" Black Cod, which are highlighted as standouts. The seafood's freshness and quality are consistently praised, with diners noting that the dishes are "cooked to perfection." The restaurant's ambiance, combined with the exceptional service, enhances the dining experience, making each meal memorable. As one reviewer puts it, the seafood here is accompanied by "superb service," ensuring that Tellers is a place where both the atmosphere and the plates are crafted with excellence.

A photo of Popei's Clam Bar & Seafood Restaurant restaurant

8. Popei's Clam Bar & Seafood Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(389)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Bethpage

Booked 3 times today

Popei's Clam Bar & Seafood Restaurant in Bethpage stands out as a beacon of Italian seafood mastery. Celebrating 40 years of family ownership, Popei's has not only won the accolade of "Best Seafood Restaurant on Long Island" by News 12 but has also captured the hearts of its patrons. Customers rave about the authenticity and quality of their dishes, with one declaring, "The seafood was sleeping in the ocean the same morning," highlighting the freshness and exquisite preparation. Another diner emphasizes the Italian flair: "Their shrimp parmigiana is sooooooo delicious with angel hair pasta." This spot isn’t just about great food; it’s about creating a memorable Italian dining experience where "every entree lets your tongue throw a party for your mouth." Whether it’s the friendly staff or the vibrant atmosphere, Popei’s delivers an authentic Italian feast that keeps diners coming back.

A photo of Limani Grille - Commack restaurant

9. Limani Grille - Commack

4.6

Exceptional(1086)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Commack

Booked 11 times today

At Limani Grille in Commack, the essence of the Mediterranean is brought to life with an authentic flair that's hard to find elsewhere. Celebrated for its traditional Greek specialties, the restaurant prides itself on using premium, first-pressed olive oil from Kalamata and capers from Santorini, ensuring each dish is as genuine as it is delightful. Guests consistently praise the "authentic, amazing, fresh and delicious" cuisine, with standout dishes like the tiger shrimp special and the beloved Sea Bass. The glowing reviews often highlight the excellent service and beautiful ambiance, making Limani Grille a top choice for anyone seeking a true taste of the Mediterranean. As one diner put it, the experience is "like grandma’s food in Greece," proving that Limani Grille is a culinary gem worth exploring.

A photo of Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille restaurant

10. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

4.5

Awesome(512)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Islip

Booked 4 times today

Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille in East Islip, NY, is a treasure trove for seafood lovers, especially famed for its "best lobster rolls on Long Island." Guests rave about the freshness and taste of the seafood, with one patron exclaiming, "Lobster rolls were fresh and tasty. Calamari was crisp and tender." The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident as Chef Mike often steps out of the kitchen to ensure diners are enjoying their meals, enhancing the dining experience with personal touches. Whether it's the New England Lobster Roll or the innovative Long Island Style Lobster Roll, Jackson Hall is a must-visit for authentic, delicious seafood that keeps patrons coming back for more.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

P
Patvip
West Palm Beach •54 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Excellent Food Brian our server was excellent. He selected the best meals for us. All was delicious 😋. Also the Chardonnay was delicious 😋 Love 💕 the experience We will definitely be back when we return to Long Island. We live in Florida Thanks again for a wonderful 70th Birthday 🎂 celebration. Patty Sinclair 561-573-5670
More info
The LakehousePrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Bay Shore
•
4.7
C
Charlesvip
New York City •118 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Best restaurant in the area. Excellent menu with many selections. The presentation was impeccable. Definitely a must go to. Great value. Staff from the hosts, servers & valet top notch.
More info
Captain Bill'sPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Bay Shore
•
4.7
S
Steven
New York State •1 review
5.0
Dined on Oct 5, 2024
We had a great time watching baseball games and fine dinning food and service were excellent.
More info
Tres Palms Coastal DiningPrice: Expensive• American• Babylon
•
4.5
F
Foodie1009vip
New York City •34 reviews
4.0
Dined on Feb 14, 2024
How fun it was to dine at White Castle for Valentine’s Day. Service was friendly and wonderful. Photo props and decorations were great. A friend, a chef, once told me the two worst days to eat in a restaurant are Mother’s Day and Valentine’s Day. This was a great way to spend Valentine’s Day while saving a more fine dining experience for another day. Such a fun experience! The food was typical WC food, but the experience made it worthwhile!
More info
White Castle - Deer ParkPrice: Moderate• American• Deer Park
•
4.8
C
cinemamanvip
New York City •50 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 4, 2023
A brand new menu was a pleasant surprise. Food and service were excellent.
More info
Red Lobster - Deer ParkPrice: Moderate• Seafood• Deer Park
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

West Islip

Seafood

Best Seafood Restaurants in West Islip

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

17 restaurants available nearby

1. The Lakehouse

2. Tres Palms Coastal Dining

3. Captain Bill's

4. White Castle - Deer Park

5. Red Lobster - Deer Park

6. Red Lobster - Copiague

7. Tellers: An American Chophouse

8. Popei's Clam Bar & Seafood Restaurant

9. Limani Grille - Commack

10. Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable