Best Seafood Restaurants in Middleton

Wonderful lunch, great service and food. We will definitely go there again!

Hands down the best seafood we've ever eaten. We had the crab cake appetizer and then split the stuffed lobster tails. Wow. The cheesecake was also good but I wish we would have asked for no seasonal (strawberry) topping as it was wonderful plain. Our server was excellent. Wish we could have gone there twice when we were in town.

Great meal and service. Thanks for hosting us, we couldn’t have had a better time. Food was delicious and service was attentive and well timed.

Last minute booking on a Monday night, friend in town who I haven't seen since before the pandemic. Our waiter Kristen was very patient with us as we were talking a lot and not paying much attention to the menu! We ordered some appetizers, entrees, dessert - everything was delicious. It was a little noisy but it was a surprisingly full house for a Monday night. Only real complaint was it was very warm in the restaurant.

Theresa's Prime is one of our favorite date night places. The food is always excellent quality, prepared well and to our liking. All of the servers and restaurant staff are well trained, polite, and very helpful. We especially enjoyed having Alan last week. He always takes great care of us and makes spot on suggestions. He gives us the right amount of attention and makes us feel special. I got the surf and turf which was a filet with their own steak sauce and 2 baked stuffed shrimp topped with asparagus. My husband got the filet. We found everything absolutely delicious. When a restaurant knows how to treat their customers, has fantastic food, and really nice ambiance you keep going back. Theresa's Prime does just that and more. We hope to get back there real soon!