Best Pizzerias in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

23 restaurants available nearby

A photo of CUCINA CAPRESE PIZZERIA & TRATTORIA restaurant

1. CUCINA CAPRESE PIZZERIA & TRATTORIA

4.6

Exceptional(114)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Old Town

Booked 3 times today

Cucina Caprese Pizzeria & Trattoria in Old Town, San Diego, stands out as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine, particularly renowned for its exceptional pizzas. Helmed by Chef Giuseppe Monaco, a native of Capri, Italy, the restaurant prides itself on traditional techniques such as using a wood-fired oven, which imparts a unique flavor profile to their dishes. Ingredients speak of authenticity and quality, with organic local produce and imports like extra virgin olive oil from Italy. Patrons rave about their experiences, with one guest exclaiming, "The most delicious pizza I have ever eaten! The crust was light and fluffy" and another highlighting, "Pizza is the best for sure! 900 degree fired oven, the dough is unbelievable!" These glowing reviews underline Cucina Caprese as a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast in San Diego.

A photo of Isola Little Italy restaurant

2. Isola Little Italy

4.7

Exceptional(753)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Little Italy

Booked 11 times today

At Isola Little Italy in San Diego, the passion for authentic Pizzeria cuisine is palpable. This gem in the heart of Little Italy is renowned for its dedication to fresh, simple ingredients that sing in every dish. Diners rave about the "best pizza in Little Italy," highlighting the wood-fired pizzas as a must-try. The signature thin crust, described as "the best pizza crust I've ever had," perfectly complements the fresh toppings and robust flavors. The ambiance, enhanced by a vine-covered building, adds to the authentic Italian experience. As one reviewer put it, "If you like pizza, you have to give this place a try." Isola Little Italy is not just a restaurant; it's a slice of Italy right in San Diego.

3. Elvira

4.9

Exceptional(413)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Ocean Beach

Booked 55 times today

Welcome to Elvira, where every slice of pizza tells a story of tradition and craftsmanship, nestled in the vibrant Ocean Beach neighborhood of San Diego. This beloved pizzeria stands out not just for its authentic Italian flavors but for the love and passion that can be tasted in every bite. Customers rave about the "authentic handmade pasta and pizza Roma style - delicious!" and declare Elvira's offerings as "the best pizza!!!" including praise for their vegan and gluten-free options. The ambiance is consistently described as cozy and inviting, making every dining experience memorable. With glowing testimonials like "Great authentic Italian food with al dente pasta and great specials!" and "The pizza was great! We tried the Super Arrabbiata, yumminess," it's clear that Elvira is a cornerstone for those seeking genuine Italian cuisine in San Diego. Whether it's the welcoming service or the meticulously crafted dishes, Elvira promises an impeccable dining experience that keeps patrons coming back.

A photo of Garage Buona Forchetta restaurant

4. Garage Buona Forchetta

4.6

Exceptional(889)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Coronado

Booked 86 times today

Garage Buona Forchetta in Coronado, San Diego, is a gem for anyone craving authentic Neapolitan pizza. Praised for its “consistently great” culinary delights, this pizzeria stands out with its “amazing and gluten-free crispy thin crust pizza,” as one reviewer highlighted its exceptional quality. The restaurant’s atmosphere is equally lauded, with its inviting ambiance and efficient service that make each visit memorable. Patrons repeatedly commend the “outstanding pricing for oceanfront dining,” ensuring a delightful experience that combines both supreme quality and value. Whether it’s the “terrifically helpful waiter” or the “endless creative topping choices” on the pizzas, Garage Buona Forchetta consistently impresses, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors in Coronado.

5. Siamo Napoli

4.7

Exceptional(1318)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • North Park

Booked 49 times today

Siamo Napoli in North Park, San Diego, stands out as a haven for authentic Napolitano style pizza, celebrated for its exceptional quality and the authenticity of its cuisine. Patrons rave about the "absolutely amazing pizzas" and the atmosphere that captures the essence of Italy. With ingredients sourced to reflect the richness of Napoli, the restaurant crafts dishes that are both traditional and innovative. Reviewers consistently praise not only the food but also the "excellent service" and the warm, inviting ambiance. A standout comment notes, "The pizza was killer, some of the best dough I’ve had outside of Napoli," highlighting the genuine Italian experience Siamo Napoli offers. Whether it's the Burrata pizza or a classic Margherita, each bite promises a slice of Naples right in San Diego.

6. Buona Forchetta

4.6

Exceptional(853)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • South Park

Booked 74 times today

Buona Forchetta in South Park, San Diego, is a treasure trove for anyone craving authentic Italian pizza. Established in 2011, this pizzeria has perfected the art of pizza making, using a specially built oven that delivers the quintessential crispy yet chewy crust that true enthusiasts rave about. Customers consistently praise the "amazing pizza" and highlight the "flavorful and cooked to perfection" crust. One review even exclaimed, "Best Italian food in South Park, San Diego highly recommend," underscoring the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity. The glowing testimonials and the bustling, warm atmosphere make Buona Forchetta the go-to spot for a slice of Italy right in the heart of San Diego.

A photo of Tavola Nostra Pizzeria E Cucina restaurant

7. Tavola Nostra Pizzeria E Cucina

4.9

Exceptional(546)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Hillcrest

Booked 9 times today

Tavola Nostra Pizzeria E Cucina, nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Hillcrest, San Diego, is a gem for lovers of authentic American cuisine with an Italian twist. Despite its deep Italian roots, the restaurant has mastered the art of blending Italian culinary traditions with American dining preferences. The reviews overwhelmingly praise its unique offerings, such as the Pinsa - an ancient style of pizza revived with modern flair. Diners rave about the “airy, crispy crust” of the Pinsa and commend the “always amazing food” and “top-tier customer service,” making Tavola Nostra a must-visit for anyone seeking a standout American dining experience.

A photo of North Italia - Fashion Valley restaurant

8. North Italia - Fashion Valley

4.7

Exceptional(2641)

Price: Expensive

• Pizzeria • Mission Valley

Booked 89 times today

North Italia in Fashion Valley, Mission Valley - San Diego, is a shining star in the realm of authentic Italian cuisine, especially noted for its exceptional Pizzeria. Patrons rave about their experiences, emphasizing the high quality and deliciousness of dishes like the prosciutto pizza and the spicy meatball pizza. One guest joyfully shares, “I love this place! The truffle bread is incredible along with the chicken pesto pasta, the margarita pizza, and the salads!” The restaurant crafts its pizzas with a commitment to authenticity, using fresh, seasonal ingredients that bring bursts of flavor in every bite. Whether it's a casual dinner or a special celebration, North Italia’s vibrant ambiance and consistent, top-notch service make it a must-visit for pizza lovers and Italian food enthusiasts alike.

A photo of Ristorante Illando restaurant

9. Ristorante Illando

4.7

Exceptional(811)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Little Italy

Booked 18 times today

Ristorante Illando, nestled in the charming neighborhood of Little Italy in San Diego, stands out as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine. Owner Leonardo Landini brings the warmth of his Florentine home to every dish served. Patrons often rave about the "authentic and amazing" Italian flavors, with standout dishes like the lobster ravioli described as "the best thing I've put in my mouth in a long time." The atmosphere is praised for its cozy trattoria vibe, reminiscent of a quaint Italian home, making every dining experience uniquely inviting. Whether it's the homemade pastas or the delicate pollo al limone, every dish at Illando promises a taste of Italy crafted with love and tradition. Guests consistently applaud the excellent service and the "quaint semi-private room that was perfect for our party," ensuring that Illando is a must-visit for anyone seeking a true Italian feast in San Diego.

10. Nonna

4.7

Exceptional(949)

Price: Moderate

• Pizzeria • Little Italy

Booked 14 times today

Nonna, nestled in the vibrant Little Italy district of San Diego, is a haven for authentic Pizzeria cuisine that delights its patrons. Known for its rustic, country-style ambiance and welcoming atmosphere, Nonna offers a slice of Sicily with its exceptional pizzas. Reviewers rave about the authenticity and freshness, with one guest exclaiming it’s “a complete gem in San Diego's Little Italy!” The pizzas are a standout, praised for their deliciousness and high-quality ingredients. As one review highlights, “Good ambience, excellent pizza, highly recommended,” encapsulating the culinary experience that awaits at Nonna. It’s an absolute must-visit for anyone craving genuine Italian flavors right in the heart of San Diego.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

E
EnriqueVIP
San Diego •165 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
We had a great time, the place is super nice and cozy, service is very welcoming, they even made special plates for us. The pastas are amazing sourcing the caccio peppe… e Will be coming back just for it. The pizza we had was not great, probably a but hard on the crust… next time I’d try one if the other pizzas. But over all a great experience
More info
ElviraPrice: Moderate• Italian• Ocean Beach
•
4.9
T
TanaVIP
San Diego •65 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
We love coming here for the great food! The service is always outstanding too.
More info
Tavola Nostra Pizzeria E CucinaPrice: Moderate• Italian• Hillcrest
•
4.9
S
SulimoniVIP
San Diego •69 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
My wife and I shared a ‘Hot Honey & Smoked Prosciutto’ pizza, and it was delicious—a perfect blend of tangy, sweet, and salty flavors on beautifully baked dough. Our server, Kendrick, was patient and attentive, and the entire staff collaborated smoothly to ensure a great experience. We sat at the window area facing the parking lot, at their new round tables, which were surprisingly comfortable and quiet. It's been a while since we’ve eaten here, and, as expected, we had a wonderful experience. Thank you!
More info
North Italia - Fashion ValleyPrice: Expensive• Italian• Mission Valley
•
4.7
J
Joan
San Diego •1 review
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Great food , setvice was good. Recommend having a reservation.
More info
Garage Buona ForchettaPrice: Moderate• Italian• Coronado
•
4.6
M
Melissa
Washington, D.C. Area •3 reviews
4.0
Dined on Dec 12, 2024
Love the food here! Sat at the enclosed outdoor patio. Lost a star due to multiple servers forgetting to provide the complimentary bread despite being asked. Good spot for families
More info
Buona ForchettaPrice: Moderate• Italian• South Park
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Pizzeria

Best Pizzerias in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

23 restaurants available nearby

1. CUCINA CAPRESE PIZZERIA & TRATTORIA

2. Isola Little Italy

3. Elvira

4. Garage Buona Forchetta

5. Siamo Napoli

6. Buona Forchetta

7. Tavola Nostra Pizzeria E Cucina

8. North Italia - Fashion Valley

9. Ristorante Illando

10. Nonna

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable