Best Pizzerias in Mahwah

Pizzeria Mandara is a wonderful place to dine! The ambiance is lovely. The wait staff are excellent! The owners and hostesses are superb! We are so grateful to know an excellent restaurant that is local.

Unquestionably the best pizza I've ever had in my 40 years of heavily Italian-cultural NYC Italian-American life, including many visits to Italy.

I've been wanting to eat here for a long time so brought my west coast sister and nephew who were craving NY pizza. Our server was awesome! The front room has a funky, lively vibe. The food was ok. My nephew had the margarita, sis had the lemon pizza and I had the pepperoni version. For someone who ate often at a famed Bushwick establishment, Parlor is only 80% as good by comparison. The crust here is too dense for me. Our salad was great but the calamari order was over-fried and our drinks were poor approximations of an old fashioned. Maybe it was just an off night given other reviews have inspired me to put this on my "must go" list. Still better than most pizza in lower Westchester and the location is iconic Rivertown so I'd say give it a try.

Everything was super tasty- fully aligned with the recommendation. Pizza was amazing ! Nothing was left in any plate !! Service was fast and the waiters were very nice. We warmly recommend this place ☺️ AND the area is very nice.

Awesome best pizza ever. Kelly is the best server so awesome