Best Italian Restaurants in Toledo

Me and my girlfriend went to the Earle for VDay. It was her first time and my second. (The first time was just as amazing.) I made reservations several weeks in advance and requested a specific bottle of wine. I did not get confirmation that they had it, so I called a few days prior to make sure. They did have it and said they were reserving it for us. Alex was our server and she was AMAZING. Very knowledgeable about the history of the restaurant. Very kind&efficient. My girlfriend and I are both actors, and I personally am also a performer/vocalist/musician. So we talked about that a lot with Alex who was very attentive. And I’m glad we did. Our bill was about $145 so I gave her $200 and told her to keep the rest for tip. She came back later and asked me to right down my Spotify artist name and the film that my gf and I just released. When I opened the folder there was only $5 in it and I asked if that was the change and she said yes. I told her I left her a $55 tip that there should have been $200. She went back to the bar that had cashed it out and told me the bartender said there was only $150…I was mortified and assured her I gave $200 and that I was a former service worker and would NEVER insult a waiter with that small of a tip. Eventually the owner came back and said they checked the drawer and indeed did find my 4 $50s that they were easy to find because they had been folded in my wallet and that they had been sticking together. I was very relieved. The food was amazing. The atmosphere was amazing. The wine, *chefs kiss*. And Alex was absolutely darling to talk to. Give that girl a raise!!! Thank you Alex for making our night so wonderful and enjoyable💜

We always look forward to the Tuesday $12 pizza nights, not just for the price, more so they are the best pizzas in the area, wood fired excellent crust. Nice fresh salads and homemade soups . A good full menu of entrees. Good selection of craft beers. Great vibe. Our waitress Sandy is always so nice and a wonderful server, she remembers our family and all of our orders each week, pretty amazing!

Really good! Pizza was amazing, wine was great, service was friendly, restaurant week discount was a nice bonus. Would definitely go back!

We had an amazing celebratory dinner. As always, the food and service was amazing. If you are looking for a great experience, be sure to try out Georgios! It remains a 5 star experience. Wendy & Axel M.

That was probably the last time we're going out to eat for the foreseeable future, because of the virus. We had a great time. It was my grandsons birthday and wanted to be with everyone one last time before isolating. We'll be back!