Best Italian Restaurants in Reynoldsburg

My partner & I came in for dinner before a show. We were seated next to a family & asked to move a table down to a more isolated table which wasn’t a problem. My cocktail was the Venetian Sunset (perfectly fruity and delicious). I ordered Branzino which was phenomenal. Seasoned perfectly and the potatoes on it were crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Delicious. My Partner got the Lamb Pappardelle, which she enjoyed but said was well seasoned (a teeny tiny bit too salty, wishes she had more noodles to balance out the sauce but I just gave her some of my potatoes instead which worked out nicely. For dessert we ordered the Lemon Cassata which was elevated and delicious. It reminded me of lemon bars but even better with the layers of cake and lemon. We loved it and left full. Our server (Our Server, Eric, burned his hand serving the Pappardelle from the hot pot & we thanked him for his sacrifice of comfort.) Eric was an amazing server, wasn’t overbearing and allowed us to enjoy our meal in peace. Would definitely return!

We dined here for my wife’s birthday and everything was perfect! The service was fantastic and we really enjoyed talking with the Sommelier, Matt. He gave us some excellent recommendations for wine and was very knowledgeable and kind. He even shared some recommendations for wineries for an upcoming trip to Oregon. The carpaccio was delicious, the endive salad was so refreshing and yummy, and the pasta was great also. It was the best meal I’ve had in a while, and the service and ambiance were awesome. Highly recommend!

Great happy hour location! Many more food and drink choices than most restaurants on their happy hour menu. Food and service were great!

Lunch at Valentina's was a delightful experience! The service was exceptional, with our server Mia being knowledgeable, friendly, and efficient. Manager Daniel went above and beyond, offering a warm welcome and securing us a lovely table by the window. The food was equally impressive – the chicken parm was a crowd-pleaser, and the swordfish was cooked to perfection. The staff was also accommodating to our special requests, making our dining experience even more enjoyable. Overall, a wonderful lunch at Valentina's!

Food and service were excellent. Staff was patient with us as we had a leisurely dinner with friends who we don’t see very often.