Best Italian Restaurants in Old Greenwich

It's just a gem. Food is excellent, owners are wonderful and you just feel at home.

Sally's Apizza is a family favorite of ours. Two medium pies feed a family of four with a little left over. Three fed a table of six. The wedge salad is delicious and the toppings varied. Be prepared to wait. The time from ordering to pizza on the table is 35-45 minutes, but the wait is worth it. The service is attentive and friendly.

Christmas dinner at Polpo's was delicious. Festive, lovely piano music and incredible food. Will definitely be my go to place for special occasions.

I’ve been to Valbella many, many times and often for a holiday. This Christmas Eve was very unusual in my experience. Our table wasn’t ready when we came in. The bar and entranceway were packed and I thought we’d never be seated. We did wait 15 minutes but apologies all around. There must have been a problem because I’ve never experienced this. Once we sat down at the best table (in front of the fireplace), all went well. The waiter was fantastic: he didn’t rush us, had a sense of humor and acted like we were his only table. Everyone enjoyed their meals. A lovely way to spend Christmas Eve.

Dinner at Tony’s was everything I wanted and more! I had an excellent fettuccine with scallops, shrimp and lobster. It was piping hot and insanely delicious. My husband had the rack of lamb which was incredibly flavorful and tender. We ended the night with the tiramisu which was something I had been craving for a few weeks (12 weeks pregnant) and it 100% satisfied that craving! The service was excellent, the ambiance was fun and Tony himself came over to thank us for coming. Highly recommend getting a meal here when you’re in the area!