Best Italian Restaurants in Valley Cottage

25 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Banchetto Feast - Nanuet restaurant

1. Banchetto Feast - Nanuet

4.6

Exceptional(465)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Nyack

Booked 11 times today

Banchetto Feast offers classic Italian dishes, decadent deserts and an extensive selection of fwines by the glass or bottle. Pasta, veal and seafood dishes are the highlights of the menu and are sure to please.

A photo of Freelance Cafe & Wine Bar restaurant

2. Freelance Cafe & Wine Bar

4.8

Exceptional(294)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Piermont

Booked 6 times today

Nestled in the picturesque village of Piermont, the Freelance Café & Wine Bar is a culinary gem lauded for its exceptional Italian cuisine. Patrons rave about the restaurant's ability to blend Italian traditions with a modern touch, making each dish a delightful experience. The menu features both "small plates and large plates," offering meticulously crafted classics like Panco crusted Cod and Tuna tatare, which have been described as "wonderful especially" by satisfied diners. Zagat rates it as "Another fabulous dining experience,” highlighting the consistent quality and creativity that Freelance Café brings to its Italian offerings. It's a place where the food not only meets but exceeds expectations, ensuring every visit is "a spectacular dining experience," as one regular exclaims. With its cozy ambiance and friendly staff, Freelance Café & Wine Bar stands out as a must-visit for authentic and innovative Italian cuisine in Piermont.

A photo of Mille Luci Pizzeria restaurant

3. Mille Luci Pizzeria

4.6

Exceptional(0)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • New City

Mille Luci Pizzeria in New City stands as a beacon of authentic Italian culinary tradition, right in the heart of Rockland County. Starting in 1968 in Brooklyn, this family-owned restaurant has perfected the art of pizza, making it not just a meal but a memorable experience. Patrons rave about the "Snow White" pizza, describing it as "absolutely delicious – each bite is a flavorful journey." With dough that ferments for three days and ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and imported cheeses, each pizza promises a taste of Italy. The ambiance is equally praised, providing a "warm and friendly" atmosphere that enhances every visit. As one reviewer puts it, it's "the best pizza I’ve ever had," making Mille Luci a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Italian pizza.

4. Vino Amore

new

(0)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Piermont

Savor the Flavors of ItalyWelcome to Vino Amore, where you can indulge in the rich flavors of Italian small plates, exquisite salumeria, and a curated selection of wines and specialty cocktails. Our passion for mixology and culinary creativity sets us apart, ensuring a memorable dining and drinking experience for all our guests.

5. The Cookery

4.7

Exceptional(1679)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Dobbs Ferry

Booked 16 times today

Nestled in the charming river town of Dobbs Ferry, The Cookery stands as a beacon of culinary excellence, offering a neo-nostalgic Italian menu that speaks volumes of Chef David DiBari’s innovative approach to simplicity. With dishes that are "amazing" and "insanely delicious," The Cookery has captured the hearts of patrons with its vibrant atmosphere and creative dishes, such as the "flawlessly executed" octopus and the melt-in-your-mouth osso bucco. Regulars and newcomers alike rave about the "perfectly cooked" pastas and the "outstanding" pig dinner for groups. As one of the best Italian spots in Westchester, The Cookery continues to delight with its lively flavors, warm service, and a menu that promises a memorable dining experience every time.

6. Fig & Tomato

4.2

Awesome(199)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Hillsdale

Booked 13 times today

Dive into the heart of Hillsdale, New Jersey, at Fig & Tomato, where Contemporary Italian cuisine meets family warmth and exceptional service. This family-owned gem shines with its vibrant culinary offerings that echo the spirit of Italy with a modern twist. Guests rave about dishes like the "fig and prosciutto pizza," a must-try starter, and the "shrimp scampi with beautifully cooked vegetables." Reviewers consistently praise the restaurant for its "consistently delicious food" and "excellent wait staff," making it clear that every meal here is both a delight and an event. As one satisfied diner puts it, "The food was fantastic...we will definitely keep this place in our rotation." Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or looking for a sumptuous meal, Fig & Tomato delivers an authentic and memorable dining experience.

7. That Supper Club

4.9

Exceptional(273)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Park Ridge

Pop Pasta Supper Club in Park Ridge, New Jersey, offers an extraordinary American dining experience that is both innovative and deeply satisfying. Blending American cuisine with global influences, Chef Nicolas Pescatore crafts a six-course menu that keeps diners coming back for more. One reviewer raves, "This place is unlike anything in New Jersey... 6 brilliantly crafted original courses." Ingredients sourced from local farms ensure freshness and support the community, adding to the authenticity and quality of every dish. The dynamic menu, changing every three weeks, promises a new adventure in American flavors with each visit. Join the supper club for an unforgettable evening where culinary craftsmanship shines.

A photo of Let's Meat Steakhouse restaurant

8. Let's Meat Steakhouse

4.6

Exceptional(295)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • River Vale

Booked 8 times today

Let's Meat Steakhouse in River Vale offers an exceptional steakhouse experience that truly stands out. Established in 2018, this culinary haven specializes in USDA dry-aged steaks, bringing together classic and innovative flavors under one roof. Patrons rave about the quality and presentation of the dishes, highlighting the "amazing Rib Eye" and the unique ambiance that makes every dining experience memorable. Reviews consistently praise the "excellent food and service," with customers noting the professional and attentive staff that enhances their visits. The mix of premium seafood and steak options, paired with a vibrant atmosphere, ensures that Let's Meat Steakhouse is a top choice for anyone craving a genuine steakhouse meal.

9. Basso56

4.7

Exceptional(1481)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Chappaqua

Booked 14 times today

Basso56, nestled in Chappaqua, Westchester County, NY, is celebrated for its exquisite Italian cuisine that brings a modern flair to traditional dishes. With rave reviews like "the best Italian in Westchester" and dishes praised as "insane," it's clear that Basso56 stands out. Patrons adore the homemade pastas, particularly the "creamy and addictive" seafood risotto and the delightful apple tart dessert. The restaurant's ambiance is equally praised, offering a "beautiful atmosphere" both indoors and outdoors. It's not just about the food; the attentive service and the overall dining experience receive high marks, making Basso56 a must-visit for authentic Italian cuisine lovers.

10. Tramonto

4.7

Exceptional(553)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Pleasantville

Booked 12 times today

Tramonto in Pleasantville, Hawthorne, epitomizes the essence of Contemporary Italian cuisine with a delightful twist on tradition. Celebrated for its "innovative Italian cuisine," Tramonto thrives on using "local, seasonal, and only the best traditional Italian ingredients." Diners consistently rave about the quality and creativity of the dishes, describing them as "always delicious" and "on par with many fine restaurants in Italy." Highlights such as the "best carbonara I have ever had" and the "insane Nutella cannolis" showcase the restaurant's commitment to excellence and authenticity. The atmosphere, complemented by rustic decor and picturesque garden views, enhances the dining experience, making Tramonto a must-visit for those seeking a remarkable Contemporary Italian meal.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

K
KaseyVIP
New York City •8 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
The wait staff is very accommodating, and Wanting to please. The drinks/Cocktails are exceptional. All in all a very nice experience. They gave a very reasonable time between courses, and even asking for the order. So much food. but very kind about wrapping up all the leftover as well. The restaurant is very well run excellent administrative staff all around! Would recommend
More info
Banchetto Feast - NanuetPrice: Moderate• Italian• Nyack
•
4.6
C
Chris
New York State •1 review
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
We’ve been going to the Cookery since it opened in 2009. We have developed an emotional connection with the restaurant. And the outstanding food isn’t the only reason. Dave DiBari pours his heart ❤️ into every plate that leaves their small kitchen. You can sense the passion with the wait staff and the other diners. We love going there and enjoying the total experience that the Cookery offers.
More info
The CookeryPrice: Moderate• Italian• Dobbs Ferry
•
4.7
A
Arthur
New York City •14 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 14, 2024
This was a first visit celebrating our friendship over the past 40 plus years. It was a late lunch and all aspects from greeting to menu selection were amazing. The food was delicious and the staff was polite, friendly and extremely professional. Overall, this was a great meal and I would definitely recommend Freelance.
More info
Freelance Cafe & Wine BarPrice: Moderate• Contemporary French / American• Piermont
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Valley Cottage

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Valley Cottage

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

25 restaurants available nearby

1. Banchetto Feast - Nanuet

2. Freelance Cafe & Wine Bar

3. Mille Luci Pizzeria

4. Vino Amore

5. The Cookery

6. Fig & Tomato

7. That Supper Club

8. Let's Meat Steakhouse

9. Basso56

10. Tramonto

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable