Best Italian Restaurants in Mayfair

45 restaurants available nearby

1. Barolo Grill

4.8

Exceptional(3823)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Cherry Creek

Booked 32 times today

Barolo Grill in Cherry Creek, Denver, stands out as a beacon of authentic Northern Italian cuisine. This award-winning restaurant prides itself on a menu that changes seasonally, featuring hand-crafted dishes from the Northern Italian provinces of Piedmont and Tuscany, using locally sourced ingredients. Reviewers rave about their experiences, mentioning "the best appetizer of my entire life" and "unbelievable cheesecake" among their culinary highlights. The attention to detail extends to their Wine Spectator Grand Award-winning wine cellar, with an extensive selection of Barolo wines, enhancing the dining experience. The knowledgeable staff, including praised servers like Gage and Tyler, offer personalized wine pairings, making each meal at Barolo Grill not just a dinner, but an authentic Italian celebration.

2. Tavernetta

4.7

Exceptional(176)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Downtown / LoDo

Booked 64 times today

Nestled in the heart of Denver's vibrant Union Station neighborhood, Tavernetta offers a slice of Italy with its authentic cuisine that has garnered accolades from the James Beard Foundation and the Michelin Guide. Guests rave about the "truly delicious" homemade focaccia and the "innovative and uniquely presented" dishes like mushroom lasagna and tagliatelle lobster pasta. Praised for its "phenomenal dining experience," Tavernetta delights with its extensive wine list and exceptional service, making every visit memorable. As one patron put it, "Everything was perfect," capturing the essence of Tavernetta's commitment to bringing the best of Italian dining to Denver.

A photo of Quality Italian- Denver restaurant

3. Quality Italian- Denver

4.7

Exceptional(3052)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Cherry Creek

Booked 84 times today

Nestled in the vibrant Cherry Creek neighborhood of Denver, Quality Italian provides a dining experience reminiscent of a classic New York City steakhouse, but with its unique twist. The restaurant has received glowing reviews for its exceptional steakhouse offerings, particularly the "filet mignon meatballs" which are described as "incredibly tender" and a dish that transports diners straight to Italy. Another standout is the "porterhouse agnolotti," praised for its rich flavors and perfect preparation. The atmosphere is consistently noted as "full of life" and "fun," making it a prime destination for both special occasions and casual outings. Regular patrons and first-time visitors alike rave about the "outstanding" service and the "always terrific" food, making Quality Italian a must-visit for anyone craving authentic and high-quality steakhouse cuisine in Denver.

A photo of North Italia – Denver restaurant

4. North Italia – Denver

4.8

Exceptional(4303)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Cherry Creek

Booked 126 times today

At North Italia in Denver's Cherry Creek neighborhood, the art of authentic Italian cuisine is celebrated with exceptional flair. Specializing in Pizzeria, North Italia's menu features pizzas that are a true testament to traditional Italian cooking, beautifully blended with modern touches. Guests rave about the "Funghi Pizza," described as "one of the best pizzas tasted anywhere," with its perfect crust and a hint of truffle oil that elevates it above the ordinary. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident, as everything is made from scratch using seasonal ingredients, ensuring each dish bursts with flavor. North Italia's vibrant atmosphere and outstanding service make it a standout destination for anyone craving genuine Italian pizza in Denver.

5. Benzina

4.8

Exceptional(565)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Park Hill

Booked 11 times today

Benzina in Park Hill, Denver, is a beacon of Pizzeria cuisine, where the magic of Neapolitan-inspired pizzas comes to life. Esteemed for its "truly outstanding" pizza crust and delectable toppings, Benzina has become a cherished spot for both locals and visitors. Reviewers rave about the quality, with comments like "best meal we've had" emphasizing their dining experiences. The restaurant’s unique ambiance, set in a converted gas station, complements its mouthwatering dishes, creating a nostalgic yet chic dining environment. Benzina isn’t just about great pizza; it's about an exceptional Italian dining experience where every meal is a masterpiece. Whether it's the "fabulous pizza" or the engaging open kitchen, Benzina stands out as a must-visit for anyone craving authentic, top-notch Italian fare in Denver.

A photo of Venice Ristorante & Wine Bar restaurant

6. Venice Ristorante & Wine Bar

4.8

Exceptional(4433)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Downtown / LoDo

Booked 68 times today

Venice Ristorante & Wine Bar in Downtown Denver is a true gem for wine lovers and enthusiasts of authentic Italian cuisine. With an impressive selection featuring over 800 wines from around the globe, including 500 Italian varieties, this venue stands out as a premier Wine Bar. Patrons rave about the "outstanding wine list" and the knowledgeable staff who help navigate the extensive options. Whether you're enjoying a casual happy hour or a special dinner, the expert pairing of exquisite wines with flavorful Italian dishes ensures a memorable experience. Reviews consistently praise the venue, noting it as "the only authentic Italian restaurant in Denver" with a wine program that is "very nice" and a bar area that is "lively and fun!" This makes Venice Ristorante & Wine Bar a must-visit for anyone seeking a top-tier wine and dining experience.

7. Shells and Sauce

4.7

Exceptional(3048)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Cherry Creek

Booked 38 times today

Shells and Sauce in Cherry Creek, Denver, is your go-to destination for heartwarming Comfort Food with an Italian-American twist. Praised for its "always delicious" dishes and "exceptional food," this local gem captures the essence of a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Patrons consistently rave about the homemade lasagna, creamy piccata, and the standout wild mushroom sachetti, describing them as "perfectly spiced and savory." The restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity shines through, with guests noting the "beautiful dinner plates" and how every visit is "an enjoyable experience." Whether it's the friendly service, the extensive wine list, or the delightful desserts like the praised orange cake, Shells and Sauce delivers an unmatched dining experience that keeps diners coming back for more. Join the many who have made this "a must in our restaurant rotation" for a taste of home-cooked excellence.

8. Osteria Marco

4.6

Exceptional(4929)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown / LoDo

Booked 46 times today

Chef-driven, artisan Italian nestled in the heart of iconic Larimer Square. Osteria Marco is fine dining quality in a casual setting. We believe in craftsmanship and artistry—pizzas hand tossed to order, pasta hand rolled daily, cheese (like our famous burrata) and salumi crafted on site. Bartenders muddle and infuse; wines evolve to reflect the variety of the Italian countryside and climate. Descend the grand staircase, hunker down and, really... try the burrata. Don't forget to join us for Drag Bingo Brunch every Sunday alongside bottomless mimosas and a scratch Italian brunch!

9. Restaurant Olivia

4.8

Exceptional(13)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Washington Park

Booked 14 times today

Restaurant Olivia is a pasta-focused restaurant located in Denver’s Wash Park neighborhood. Olivia is the second project from chef Ty Leon, beverage guru Austin Carson, and hospitality maven Heather Morrison. Each evening we open the doors to our restaurant as if it were our home, welcoming guests with warmth and graciousness. We believe you’ll feel our attention to hospitality the minute you step inside.We draw inspiration from classic Italian dishes and the traditions that bring them to life, but we also feature flavors and recipes from around the world. Our food is made with care and intention. We source our ingredients from organic and local producers whenever possible. Our beverage program features expertly-crafted but playful cocktails, alongside an Italian-focused wine list. We look forward to sharing with you our passion for outstanding food and service.

10. Coperta

4.7

Exceptional(1625)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Uptown

Booked 18 times today

At Coperta in Uptown, Denver, the essence of Southern Italy is vividly brought to life through its authentic farm-to-table cuisine. Specializing in the robust flavors of Rome and Southern Italy, this restaurant's commitment to sourcing high-quality local ingredients is evident in every dish. Guests rave about the freshness and authenticity, with one diner exclaiming, “The food was absolutely delicious...everything we had was incredibly delicious. Such high quality food for an affordable price.” Coperta doesn’t just serve meals; it crafts an experience steeped in Italian culinary tradition, enhanced by a charming old-school décor and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether it’s their delectable pastas or the house-made ice cream, every bite at Coperta is a celebration of farm-fresh goodness and Italian culinary craftsmanship.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

T
Tj
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
What a lovely trattoria. Great service from maitre’ d Seth, my server Alane and her support team. The food was excellent, gnocchi and polenta stole my heart as well as the authentic and mouthwatering puntarelle insalata. Approachable in all areas for the casual diner to the elegant wine savant. 10/10.
More info
TavernettaPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Downtown / LoDo
•
4.7
C
Courtney
Denver / Colorado •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
We were a large party of 9. We were welcomed and seated immediately. Drinks and food came out fast. The staff was so patient with us taking our time to decided between multiple amazingly sounding foods. When the food came out, it was off the charts amazing. I frequent the Holly St location of this establishment and have never been disappointed so I had similar expectations here and it was everything I expected. The rest of party had never been before and they were raving about the food and asking to come back. We will definitely be back.
More info
Venice Ristorante & Wine BarPrice: Moderate• Italian• Downtown / LoDo
•
4.8
N
Neal
Baltimore / Maryland •72 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Fantastic!!! Will definitely return when in Denver. Place was busy hopping, but all staff worked hard to keep things moving smoothly. Jordan, our waiter crushed it. Outstanding attention & service. Treat her well cuz she is the best advertising your restaurant can have. Food also awesome from presentation to taste and menu choice great.
More info
North Italia – DenverPrice: Moderate• Italian• Cherry Creek
•
4.8
B
Bentonvip
Denver / Colorado •14 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
This place is outstanding. Crowded but not overwhelming. Menu is limited, in a good way. The restaurant presents a number of simple and complex options, and everything tastes as fresh as can possibly be. We started with dressed oysters, then a kale salad - both dishes perfectly prepared. Then lobster pasta, and salmon, again extremely fresh. The complimentary table rolls are also nostalgically warm, buttery and seasoned with salt and garlic. I'd only been here for lunch, but definitely coming back for dinner soon!
More info
Quality Italian- DenverPrice: Expensive• Italian• Cherry Creek
•
4.7
L
Lawrencevip
Anchorage / Alaska •33 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
We live out of state and wanted to take my mom out to a great dinner while we were in Denver. We went there with high expectations based on the reviews and my wife being from northern Italy and we were pleasantly surprised by the quality of service and food. Our tajarin con conigelio was one if the highlights of the evening.
More info
Barolo GrillPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Cherry Creek
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Mayfair

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Mayfair

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

45 restaurants available nearby

1. Barolo Grill

2. Tavernetta

3. Quality Italian- Denver

4. North Italia – Denver

5. Benzina

6. Venice Ristorante & Wine Bar

7. Shells and Sauce

8. Osteria Marco

9. Restaurant Olivia

10. Coperta

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable