Best Italian Restaurants in Fortville

Food was really good. Our server was good. We ordered a wedge salad and and pizza. After 20 minutes I had to find our server to ask for our salads. Of course she apologized but had them immediately. Our pizza came 10 minutes later. Just really slow out of the kitchen for not being very busy.

Absolutely love the pasta but stay for dessert! The panettone bread pudding was sooo yummy! Simone and Beth have created a n atmosphere and menu The Best by far! Try the pasta e fagioli! Unstoppable flavor!

Incredible!! Hidden gem - everything was perfect - food, service, ambience, wine list - and the staff is amazing! Everything made in house. Authentic Italian - they bring in flour from Italy so it’s not so heavy. Sauces are done perfectly as are the portions. Great wine list with American wines in case you don’t know Italian wines. Buon appetito!!

What a gem in downtown Pendleton!! The atmosphere is classy but not intimidating. You can have a conversation with your table of guests without having to talk over loud background music. The food is amazing! Authentic Italian cuisine that will make you want to come back again and again. Not only is the Cheese Wheel Pasta an experience like no other it is absolutely delicious. Fresh ingredients all around and homemade pasta make Catello's a cut above. The service was excellent. The staff is knowledgeable, friendly and the right amount of attentive. An added bonus is the grocery area at the back of the restaurant. Authentic Italian meats and cheeses sliced to order, fresh pasta and sauces, homemade gelato and other desserts are available for purchase. Catello's is absolutely worth the drive and we can't wait to go back!

Great experience, celebrated a birthday! Everything was great except the table water. It tasted like dirt.