Best Italian Restaurants in Fisher Island

108 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Gianni's at the Former Versace Mansion restaurant

1. Gianni's at the Former Versace Mansion

4.5

Price: Expensive

• Italian • South Beach

Booked 246 times today

Gianni's at the Former Versace Mansion in South Beach, Miami Beach, is a culinary gem renowned for its exquisite Mediterranean cuisine. Nestled in the historic Villa Casa Casuarina, Gianni's offers a dining experience that combines authentic Italian Mediterranean flavors with a luxurious, one-of-a-kind atmosphere. Reviewers rave about the "amazing" truffle gnocchi and the "outstanding" octopus appetizer, noting that the dishes are "exquisitely delicious" and the presentation "gorgeous." With glowing testimonials like "Best restaurant I've ever been to" and "food and drinks are AMAZING," it's clear that Gianni's stands out for its quality and authenticity. Whether it's for a special occasion or a delightful culinary exploration, Gianni's promises an unforgettable Mediterranean dining experience right in the heart of Miami Beach.

2. CALL ME GABY

4.8

Exceptional(2274)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • South Beach

Booked 124 times today

Welcome to Call me Gaby!Miss Gaby welcomes you to experience and enjoy beautiful and amazing cocktails crafted by our Mixologists- MISS GABY BAR 2nd floor upstairs is open everyday from 12.00am to 2.00am.- MISS GABY WILL BE OPEN ONLY FOR DRINKS AND THE BAR WILL BE FIRST COME FIRST SERVE.We are located at 22 Washington Avenue in Miami Beach. Enjoy gourmet pizza and casual fare in our magical setting South of Fifth.FOR RESERVATIONS SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE TO +1 7867477145WE WILL NOT TAKE ANY RESERVATION BY PHONE AND INSTAGRAM Our outdoor seating is NOT guaranteed. We Will seat guest upon availability .Due to the high volume of guest that we have, we ask for our table back in 2 hours up to 6 guests, to give other guest an opportunity to dine with us.

3. Forte dei Marmi

4.6

Exceptional(1964)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • South Beach

Booked 94 times today

Forte dei Marmi in South Beach, Miami Beach, exemplifies the pinnacle of Organic Italian cuisine. By exclusively using the finest local organic produce, farm-raised meats, and wild-caught seafood, they ensure every dish served is of the highest quality. The dedication to slow food culture shines in their menu, creating an authentic dining experience that resonates with diners. Patrons rave about their experiences, with glowing remarks like “Phenomenal meal, service and the pistachio gelato was a showstopper!” and “Best Cacio e Pepe ever.” The commitment to organic and biodynamic ingredients extends to their wine and cocktail program, enhancing the overall dining experience at Forte dei Marmi.

A photo of Cecconi's Miami Beach restaurant

4. Cecconi's Miami Beach

4.7

Exceptional(4150)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • South Beach

Booked 124 times today

Cecconi's Miami Beach is a gem in South Beach, offering an authentic Mediterranean dining experience that consistently impresses. With its Venetian-inspired menu, the restaurant serves up dishes that are both simple and extraordinary, capturing the essence of Mediterranean flavors. Guests rave about their experiences, highlighting the "fantastic scallops" and "unbelievably good focaccia bread," which alone could satisfy any palate. The ambiance, described as a "beautiful outdoor dining garden," complements the culinary delights, making every meal a memorable event. Cecconi’s commitment to quality and service shines, with visitors noting the "excellent food and attentive but not overbearing service." It’s a must-visit for anyone looking for an authentic, high-quality Mediterranean meal in Miami Beach.

A photo of Ocean Grill at The Setai restaurant

5. Ocean Grill at The Setai

4.6

Exceptional(2342)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • South Beach

Booked 119 times today

At Ocean Grill at The Setai, located in the vibrant South Beach, Miami Beach, guests are treated to an authentic Mediterranean culinary journey. The open-air setting, surrounded by tropical foliage and soothing ocean breezes, sets the stage for a menu that shines with Mediterranean brilliance. The wood-fired grill infuses dishes like the Spanish Octopus and Mediterranean Branzino with rustic charm. Reviews rave about the "delicious food," with the White Truffle Pizza and Yellowfin Tuna Tartare being crowd favorites. As one diner puts it, the food and ambiance are "to die for," making Ocean Grill a must-visit for anyone craving a taste of the Mediterranean in Miami.

6. Prime Italian

4.7

Exceptional(3340)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • South Beach

Booked 48 times today

Prime Italian in South Beach, Miami Beach, is a must-visit for steak enthusiasts. Known for its upscale American-Italian offerings, this sister restaurant to Prime One Twelve truly excels in its steak cuisine. Reviewers rave about the culinary experience, with one guest exclaiming, "Steaks were great," and another emphasizing the perfection of their "bone-in filet." The quality of the food consistently impresses, from the "wonderful group dinner" experiences to the "top notch" service that accompanies each meal. Prime Italian not only promises large, delicious portions but an atmosphere that complements its mouthwatering steak selections, making it a standout destination for both locals and tourists alike.

7. Casadonna

4.5

Awesome(250)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Downtown Miami

Booked 21 times today

Casadonna is a Coastal Italian-inspired waterfront restaurant developed in partnership between Groot Hospitality and Tao Group Hospitality. It is housed in the same Mediterranean revival building as Miami’s historic Women’s Club, located in the city’s burgeoning Edgewater neighborhood. In fact, the name “Casadonna” is derived from the setting—it is a fusion of Italian words translating to “house of the woman.”Riviera-style Italian cooking serves as the heart of Casadonna’s cuisine. The menu features the freshest and finest local and imported products, with signature handcrafted dishes. Plates are based around traditional recipes found in the coastal towns of Naples, Taormina, Bari, Positano and Gaeta, and each is presented in a contemporary fashion. Bespoke cocktails and an extensive wine list will complement this approach.

A photo of Osteria Positano Italian Restaurant Miami Beach restaurant

8. Osteria Positano Italian Restaurant Miami Beach

4.6

Exceptional(168)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • South Beach

Booked 34 times today

Osteria Positano, located in the vibrant South Beach, Miami Beach, is a gem for authentic Pizzeria cuisine. Drawing inspiration from the stunning Amalfi Coast, it offers a slice of Italy with a modern twist. Diners rave about the authenticity and quality, with one guest exclaiming, "This is the best pizza I have ever had." The restaurant's dedication to tradition and quality shines through in dishes like the praised "Pizza salami" and the classic "margarita pizza," which are both must-tries. The atmosphere, reminiscent of Positano itself, paired with exceptional service, makes Osteria Positano a top destination for both locals and tourists seeking genuine Italian pizza.

9. Torno Subito

4.5

Awesome(151)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Downtown Miami

Booked 25 times today

An ironic and contemporary approach to Italian cuisine, Torno Subito Miami features traditional staples alongside innovative dishes inspired by Miami's rich history, culture and landscape. Each dish tells a unique story, taking guests on a culinary journey that reflects the restaurant’s core value of combating food waste. At the helm is Chef Bernardo Paladini, the creative force behind Torno Subito Dubai's inaugural Michelin star.

A photo of The Deck at Island Gardens restaurant

10. The Deck at Island Gardens

4.5

Awesome(880)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Downtown Miami

Booked 26 times today

The Deck at Island Gardens, located in the vibrant heart of Downtown Miami, is a premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine with a Mediterranean twist. Celebrated for its chic waterfront ambiance and stunning views of Biscayne Bay, this restaurant offers an unforgettable dining experience. Patrons rave about the "spectacular food" and "top tier service," making it clear that The Deck excels in both quality and atmosphere. With its "amazing Sunday brunch" and vibrant dinner parties, the restaurant provides a perfect blend of culinary excellence and lively entertainment. As one reviewer puts it, it's a "MUST see place in Miami," where the Italian flavors are as captivating as the panoramic vistas. Whether it's the charred octopus or the lobster risotto, each dish is crafted to perfection, promising a truly exquisite taste of Italy right in the heart of Miami.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

OT
OpenTable DinerVIP
Chicago / Illinois •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
love cecconis!!! always good, we did get charged for one dessert we didn’t order, but other than that, it was perfect!
More info
Cecconi's Miami BeachPrice: Expensive• Italian• South Beach
•
4.7
A
ArchanaVIP
New York City •5 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Excellent Food! Excellent Service! Great Ambience. Its a bit pricey but definitely worth it!
More info
CALL ME GABYPrice: Expensive• Italian• South Beach
•
4.8
J
Jean-PierreVIP
Montreal / Quebec •6 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Awesome venue, the staff, the food and the ambiance were just great, would definitely go back, A+++
More info
Ocean Grill at The SetaiPrice: Expensive• International• South Beach
•
4.6
F
Fay
Toronto / Ontario •1 review
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
The mansion does not fail! It was beautiful like always! Great food and the staff (servers) were very very sweet. Especially our one server. The girls at the front can look a bit unfriendly, to the point that makes you a bit unwelcome but overall it was a beautiful Christmas Day at the Versace mansion. Maybe a little renovation on the chairs would be good too. It is price friendly (kinda) so in my opinion, the furniture should reflect the “luxury” look. At least a good cleanup. The food was really good, we had the spaghetti with lobster.. the burrata was amazing.. drinks pretty good.. no complaints at all! Thank you for making our Christmas 2025 beautiful all the way from Canada!
More info
Gianni's at the Former Versace MansionPrice: Expensive• Italian• South Beach
•
4.5
V
ViktoryiaVIP
Washington, D.C. Area •21 reviews
5.0
Dined on Dec 18, 2024
Forte dei Marmi offers an exceptional dining experience with its elegant ambiance and authentic Italian cuisine. The food is perfectly prepared, with fresh ingredients that highlight traditional flavors. Francesco, our server, went above and beyond to make our evening unforgettable with his warm hospitality and impeccable attention to detail. His recommendations were spot-on, and he ensured every aspect of our meal was flawless. This restaurant is a must-visit for anyone looking for a true taste of Italy with outstanding service!
More info
Forte dei MarmiPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• South Beach
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Fisher Island

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Fisher Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

108 restaurants available nearby

1. Gianni's at the Former Versace Mansion

2. CALL ME GABY

3. Forte dei Marmi

4. Cecconi's Miami Beach

5. Ocean Grill at The Setai

6. Prime Italian

7. Casadonna

8. Osteria Positano Italian Restaurant Miami Beach

9. Torno Subito

10. The Deck at Island Gardens

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable