Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Bensonhurst

43 restaurants available nearby

1. Café Mars

4.9

Exceptional(78)

Price: Very Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Park Slope

Booked 11 times today

Café Mars is an unusual Italian restaurant. Come see what we mean!For parties larger than 6 please email info@cafemarsbk.com to help craft your hassle free dining experience!

2. Pastavino

4.8

Exceptional(373)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Stapleton

Booked 10 times today

Pastavino, nestled in the charming neighborhood of Stapleton, Staten Island, offers a sublime fusion of contemporary Italian cuisine with a touch of traditional charm. Helmed by Michelin Star Chef Josh Laurano, the restaurant prides itself on seasonal, locally-sourced ingredients, bringing out the soul of its meticulously crafted dishes. Diners rave about the homemade pastas and focaccia, describing them as "always delicious" and "exceptional." The elegant ambiance, complemented by waterfront views, makes Pastavino a favorite for both special occasions and casual dining. Enthusiastic reviews often highlight the "amazing food & service," making it a recommended destination for anyone seeking a genuine taste of Italy with a modern twist.

A photo of Gargiulo's Coney Island restaurant

3. Gargiulo's Coney Island

4.9

Exceptional(803)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Coney Island

Booked 6 times today

At Gargiulo's Coney Island, nestled in the vibrant heart of Brooklyn, you'll discover a slice of Italy renowned for its authenticity and rich tradition. Celebrated for its "divine" Italian cuisine, Gargiulo’s serves up traditional Neapolitan dishes crafted from family recipes that have been cherished since 1907. Patrons rave about the "outstanding" Trofie pasta with pesto and the "perfect" lamb chops, highlighting the fresh, high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere is described as an "Italian villa," adding to the authentic experience. As one reviewer put it, the house-made cannoli is "out of this world," making Gargiulo's a must-visit for anyone seeking the true essence of Italian dining in New York City.

4. Pizza Secret

4.3

Awesome(91)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Park Slope

Booked 3 times today

Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Park Slope, Brooklyn, Pizza Secret stands out as a gem for authentic Neapolitan pizza. Celebrated for its age-old wood-fired brick oven, this eatery promises not just traditional pizza but a slice of Naples itself. Patrons rave about the "best pizza Napoletana" and applaud the "amazing pizza and great customer service!" With glowing reviews like "the pizza tasted just like it is made in Naples" and "hands down the best pizza I've ever eaten in Brooklyn," it's clear that Pizza Secret delivers both exceptional flavors and a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Pizza Secret offers a true taste of Italy right in the heart of Brooklyn.

5. Cafe Luna - Hylan

4.8

Exceptional(13)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • Concord

Booked 2 times today

Cafe Luna in Concord, Staten Island, is a beacon of Contemporary Italian cuisine, particularly celebrated for its exceptional seafood and authentic Neapolitan pizza. Patrons rave about dishes like the black linguine with shrimp and the red snapper marechiara, describing them as "out of this world." The restaurant's atmosphere, with its ocean-inspired decor, complements the culinary experience, making it both "fun and fine." Reviewers consistently highlight the quality and generous portions, with remarks like "food is excellent and plentiful!" and "best Italian food in Staten Island." The attentive and knowledgeable staff further enrich the dining experience, ensuring every meal at Cafe Luna is memorable and satisfying.

A photo of Malone's Chop House restaurant

6. Malone's Chop House

4.6

Exceptional(69)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • Bay Ridge

Booked 7 times today

Malone's Chop House, nestled in the heart of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, offers a stellar Contemporary Italian dining experience that stands out for its quality and authenticity. With three chefs boasting a combined 60 years of fine dining expertise, Malone's serves up Italian cuisine with a modern twist that consistently impresses. Diners rave about the perfectly cooked filet mignon and grilled octopus, highlighting dishes like the "delicious" potato pie and the "fabulous" steak. The restaurant's atmosphere and service receive equal praise, described as "impeccable" and "attentive," making every meal memorable. As one satisfied guest puts it, "Malone's is a must-go-to restaurant!" This spot is a gem for those seeking exquisite Contemporary Italian fare in Brooklyn.

7. Cecconi's Dumbo

4.5

Awesome(5194)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • DUMBO

Booked 210 times today

Cecconi's Dumbo, nestled in the picturesque DUMBO neighborhood of Brooklyn, offers a sublime Mediterranean dining experience that harmonizes beautifully with its stunning waterfront views of the Manhattan skyline. This restaurant is celebrated for its "delicious Mediterranean classics like the Roman style gnocchi and risotto" that transport diners straight to Italy with each bite. Reviewers consistently rave about the authenticity and quality of the cuisine, noting dishes like "octopus, tuna tartare Cecconi’s style, and zucchini Fritti" as must-tries. A guest highlighted, "If you wanna taste real Italian food, this is the place!" With its "fabulous view and great service," Cecconi's Dumbo promises not just a meal, but a memorable Mediterranean feast that's always "on point."

8. Il Fiorista

4.5

Awesome(239)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • NoMad

Booked 39 times today

Il Fiorista in NoMad, New York, is a Mediterranean culinary gem that truly stands out for its commitment to quality and authenticity. Nestled just a short walk from Madison Square Park, this restaurant excels in incorporating fresh, local, and seasonal produce into its dishes, much like traditional Mediterranean cuisine. Guests rave about their experiences, with one noting, "the food was absolutely delicious, every bite was so yummy and stunningly presented!" Another guest praised the restaurant's ambiance and service, saying, "the design evokes the calm beauty of the flowers that give its name, the service is impeccable and warm." At Il Fiorista, the attention to detail, from the botanical ingredients to the beautifully crafted dishes, ensures a Mediterranean dining experience that is both delightful and memorable.

A photo of Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad restaurant

9. Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad

4.5

Awesome(347)

Price: Expensive

• Contemporary italian • NoMad

Booked 60 times today

Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad in the vibrant NoMad neighborhood of New York offers an exquisite taste of Mediterranean cuisine with an Italian flair. Patrons rave about the "delicious Italian plates," highlighting the "finest quality" ingredients and "impeccable service." The restaurant's ambiance, featuring hand-chipped mosaic floors and plush seating, perfectly complements its sophisticated yet inviting atmosphere. Reviewers consistently praise dishes like the "best fusilli pomodoro I have ever had" and the "fresh, locally caught fish," underscoring Cecconi's commitment to quality and authenticity. With its elegant setting and renowned Mediterranean offerings, Cecconi's remains a top choice for a memorable dining experience in Manhattan.

10. Sogno Toscano

4.8

Exceptional(103)

Price: Moderate

• Contemporary italian • West Village

Booked 19 times today

Sogno Toscano in West Village, New York, offers a truly authentic Italian Wine Bar experience that transports you straight to Tuscany. Diners rave about the "immaculate food, wine, vibes, and service," with a special mention for the "Lambrusco and charcuterie board that make you think you’re in Italy." This gem is known for its extensive selection of imported wines that perfectly complement their gourmet offerings. As one happy guest put it, "the wine is top notch," underscoring the quality that Sogno Toscano prides itself on. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Sogno Toscano provides a perfect slice of Italy with its exceptional wine and food pairings, making every visit a memorable one.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

S
Scott
New York City •25 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Went to celebrate a birthday. I love the whole vibe of the restaurant. All our cocktails were delicious. We ordered a few appetizers, including the flatbread, which were amazing. All our entrées were delicious. The service was terrific. Our server was extremely friendly and helpful and never did we feel rushed? I would highly recommend, this restaurant to anyone
More info
PastavinoPrice: Expensive• Italian• Stapleton
•
4.8
J
Joseph
San Antonio •10 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 14, 2024
Always a wonderful meal! Wait staff are well trained and attentive!
More info
Gargiulo's Coney IslandPrice: Expensive• Italian• Coney Island
•
4.9
OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined on Nov 9, 2024
Excellent spot! Contemporary, modern plays on Italian classics. Staff is super attentive and friendly. Will be going back soon!
More info
Café MarsPrice: Very Expensive• Contemporary Italian• Park Slope
•
4.9
B
barbara
Greater Boston •25 reviews
5.0
Dined on Nov 9, 2024
It was a good dinner , food was very good , large portions and good service
More info
Cafe Luna - HylanPrice: Moderate• Italian• Concord
•
4.8
A
Adrianavip
New York City •34 reviews
5.0
Dined on Oct 27, 2024
Pizza secret was a great find. Service was excellent. We were greeted immediately and our waitress was attentive. Taking our order in a timely manner and attentive. Food was delicious. Only thing I wish they did was add more sauce to their margarita pie. It was all dough and it really missed more sauce and something to dial up the flavor. Otherwise the rest of the meal was excellent (meatballs, rice balls, and the Americana pizza (which I highly recommend)).
More info
Pizza SecretPrice: Moderate• Contemporary Italian• Park Slope
•
4.3

Explore OpenTable

Bensonhurst

Contemporary italian

Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Bensonhurst

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

43 restaurants available nearby

1. Café Mars

2. Pastavino

3. Gargiulo's Coney Island

4. Pizza Secret

5. Cafe Luna - Hylan

6. Malone's Chop House

7. Cecconi's Dumbo

8. Il Fiorista

9. Cecconi's at The Ned NoMad

10. Sogno Toscano

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable