Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Vineyard Haven

Went for Valentines weekend. Dinner was magnificent surf and turf (filet and 2 shrimp) served with creamy cheesy mash potatoes and asparagus was out of this world! Real romantic setting fir special occasions. We stayed next door at the Pelgam Resort which was an added treat. Gorgeous rooms overlooking the Sound. Once in a lifetime occasion.

We ordered the special Wygau for two with mash potatoes and brussel sprouts. For $80 I expected more food. I understand the steak is expensive, that wasn't the issue. There was barely any brussel sprouts and not enough mashed potatoes. Our server Stephanie was attentive although it was very busy due to Valentines day. Overall a good experience. Very modern restaurant will come back

Party of three in the perfect igloo for a beautiful sunset. The service was very good. Calamari , chowder, clam fritters, lobster pasta and short rib tacos were all exceptionally delicious! We will return to The Reef.

One of our favorite island restaurants. Always guaranteed to get a great meal. The food always tastes delicious. Perfectly seasoned with great flavors. Never bland. Service always great from the hostess to the servers to the bussers.

We ate an anniversary dinner at the Inn, a wonderful four-course meal of oysters, lobster, braised short ribs, and sea bass. Everything was delicious, and we're excited to return. Below is a fuller review of the Inn itself: We had a wonderful time at Lambert's Cove Inn. We stayed one night for our anniversary. Upon arriving to the island, we received two messages from the staff via text. This was wonderful as it allowed us to request early check-in. When we got to the Inn, we were greeted by Galen and Anna. They informed us that we could check in early and gave us a tour of the Inn. The grounds are spectacular. We were very happy to have arrived early as it provided time to take a leisurely walk to the pond, through lush flowers and plans, and near the alpacas. The room was cozy and had a private balcony, which was lovely. The staff had left us a bottle of Prosecco for our anniversary. This little detail was amazing.