Best Bistros in Rutherford

Miss Nellie’s was an absolute gem of a find! I visited on a Saturday night with a friend for a pre-Christmas dinner, and it couldn’t have been a better experience. The restaurant was beautifully and tastefully decorated for the holidays, setting the perfect festive atmosphere. The food was phenomenal—everything we tried was a hit! We started with the Irish Espresso Martini, and it was easily one of the best I’ve ever had. I liked it so much that I immediately texted some fellow espresso martini enthusiasts to recommend this spot. For appetizers, we shared the Nashville Chicken Bites and Crabcake Arancini, both of which were delicious. For our main course, we both ordered the Chicken Vodka Parmesan. It was flavorful, perfectly cooked, and an instant favorite. To end the meal, we split the Sticky Toffee Pudding, which was absolutely divine—a must-try for dessert lovers! Beyond the incredible food, the service at Miss Nellie’s was impeccable. Every waiter was so friendly and attentive, making it one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. If you’re looking for a place with amazing food, exceptional service, and a warm, festive ambiance, Miss Nellie’s should be at the top of your list. I can’t wait to return!

The risotto was wonderfully warm fuel for a typical winter day on the patio. Thanks to the team for a great retreat!

Milling Room is a great spot for a date night meal. The ambiance and styling aim to impress which it did. The food is above average without going over the top in either presentation or price. Just watch out for the drink prices. The waiter up charged by 50% for a Hendrix martini, without informing, then tried to pass it off that I should have known the menu price was well liquor. Despite the blatant attempt at a rip off, I will be back

This spot was the perfect tea room experience. The size of the tea room allows for a more intimate experience. Also, it feels like a real tea room, rather than a hotel restaurant with tea. The food was amazing and the individuals teas for each person were just great. Would 10/10 recommend for a special experience.

Second time here. The staff are so wonderful. They are incredibly accommodating and so friendly. The food is also quite tasty!