Best American Restaurants in North Stonington

Ella’s did not disappoint! We go to Ella’s often and we have never been disappointed! Christmas Eve dinner was flawless. Dinner was relaxed, not rushed. Our waiter, Randy, was attentive and accommodating. The food was beyond delicious. We can not wait to go back again! Thank you Ella’s for always going above and beyond on every level.

As usual, dining at David Burke’s is always an incredible experience. I had the lobster tail and filet special. It was delicious and cooked to order. My husband had the sea bass, which was a light meal, but excellent as well. We also had a dessert martini flight to finish the night. It was a unique dessert, which was wonderful. I liked that they had a special Christmas Eve/ Christmas menu. Although pricey, I would highly recommend dining at David Burke’s.

This is an excellent indie restaurant—food is homie but creative. Service is the friendliest on either side of the Pawcatuck. Only knock is on the clam chowder which is a bit thick, starchy or gelatinous rather than creamy from dairy. But then I’m a very fussy chowdah lover.

Great food, service and ambiance! I will definitely be back!

We have wanted to try Tin Peddler for a while, and had the perfect opportunity for a family brunch. We had an 11:00 a.m. reservation, and when we arrived the hostess informed us that they were running a little behind, so we had a 10 minute wait to be seated which was no big deal. The brunch menu is lovely. The drink menu offered wonderful brunch cocktail selections (including mocktails), and the food menu had a really nice selection of both breakfast and more savory lunch options. Everyone said their food was exceptional. Our party ordered a variety of items, including traditional breakfasts, butternut bisque, avocado toast and grilled cheese, all delicious. One funny thing that happened was the bus person took our plates before asking if we were finished, and before we realized what was happening, my son was left holding the last bites of his breakfast sandwich while his plate was cleared away. We all laughed, but this is just a little fine tuning that their staff should be trained on. The restaurant decor is really fun and inviting. The noise level did get loud at times but that seems to be common in restaurants these days because of the decor and furnishings they use, and the open concept layout. Definitely not a deal breaker. All in all we had a wonderful experience and look forward to returning to try their dinner menu!