Best American Restaurants in Middletown

26 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Semolina Restaurant restaurant

1. Semolina Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(3164)

Price: Expensive

• American • Red Bank

Booked 37 times today

Semolina Restaurant in Red Bank, New Jersey, epitomizes the essence of farm-to-table dining with its dedication to fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. Celebrated for its homemade pastas and a menu that adapts to the seasons, Semolina offers a dining experience that is both authentic and delightful. Patrons rave about the quality of the dishes with comments like "The balance of flavors is so well executed" and "The food is always amazing." This BYO gem ensures each dish, from the half roasted chicken to the perfectly prepared pasta, showcases the best local produce, making every meal a testament to the culinary treasures of New Jersey. Whether it's your first visit or you're a regular, Semolina's commitment to excellence and warm, accommodating service promises a memorable dining experience every time.

A photo of Houlihan's - Holmdel restaurant

2. Houlihan's - Holmdel

4.6

Exceptional(592)

Price: Moderate

• American • Holmdel

Booked 5 times today

Since 1972, we’ve believed in quality ingredients, cooking from scratch and having fun. From our famous ‘Shrooms and Stuffed Chicken Breast to our unique burger blend and ahi tuna, we believe in celebrating the small things and that every moment deserves a toast in its honor. So grab a drink (perhaps our signature Long Island Iced Tea), enjoy some great conversation and let us serve you an excellent meal.

A photo of The Goat by David Burke restaurant

3. The Goat by David Burke

4.3

Awesome(928)

Price: Moderate

• American • Union Beach

Booked 14 times today

At The Goat by David Burke in Union Beach, the essence of authentic American cuisine is elevated through the expert hands of celebrity chef David Burke. This vibrant locale delights patrons with its unique blend of Italian-American dishes, each prepared with a creative twist and an emphasis on quality. Reviews consistently praise the restaurant's offerings, with one diner exclaiming, "The food at The GOAT never disappoints; it is always delicious!" From the ethereal carbonara to the perfectly cooked filet and inventive clothesline bacon, every dish is a testament to the chef's mastery and passion for American cooking. The GOAT is not just a meal; it’s an experience, making it a must-visit destination for anyone seeking the pinnacle of American dining.

A photo of The Robinson Ale House - Red Bank restaurant

4. The Robinson Ale House - Red Bank

4.8

Exceptional(1498)

Price: Expensive

• American • Red Bank

Booked 29 times today

At The Robinson Ale House in Red Bank, the essence of a classic bistro is brilliantly captured, offering guests an inviting mix of traditional charm and contemporary flair. Renowned for its craft beers and inventive burgers, this bistro stands out for its commitment to quality and authenticity. Patrons rave about the "delicious nachos" and "perfectly executed drinks," highlighting the great dining experience. One reviewer encapsulated the sentiment by noting, "Food is always outstanding. Nice atmosphere too." Whether it's the French Onion Soup or the Wedge Salad, every dish is crafted to perfection, making The Robinson Ale House a must-visit destination for bistro aficionados in Red Bank.

A photo of Triumph Restaurant & Brewery restaurant

5. Triumph Restaurant & Brewery

4.5

Awesome(512)

Price: Moderate

• American • Red Bank

Booked 8 times today

Triumph Restaurant & Brewery in Red Bank is not just a brewery; it's a haven for beer garden enthusiasts who crave authenticity and quality. With its diverse and expertly crafted beer selection, guests rave about experiences such as enjoying a "delicious" outdoor dining alongside "lovely rustic area with an overhang and greenery" that complements the vibrant live music scene. One patron exclaimed about the "elegant" ambiance while sipping on the house-made lagers, with others praising the "interesting and varied beer menu" that perfectly pairs with their gastro-pub offerings. It's clear Triumph's Beer Garden is a cherished spot, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine and enjoyable beer garden experience.

A photo of The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn restaurant

6. The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn

4.6

Exceptional(1247)

Price: Expensive

• American • Red Bank

Booked 10 times today

The Molly Pitcher Inn prides itself not only in its fine dining menu but also its service and atmosphere. It is an ideal setting for that special occasion or just an elegant dining experience. Under the crystal chandeliers of our Dining Room, we serve some the most tantalizing cuisine in all of New Jersey. Our panoramic windows provide a truly breathtaking vista. No matter what season or time of day, the quiet stillness of the Navesink River envelops all who dine here.

7. Elli’s Backyard

4.6

Exceptional(416)

Price: Moderate

• American • Red Bank

Booked 6 times today

Step into the sweet splendor of Elli’s Backyard in Red Bank, NJ, where dessert isn't just a dish but a divine experience. Renowned for its unique and delightful treats, this family-owned gem offers an unforgettable end to any meal. Patrons rave about the decadent flourless chocolate cake and the whimsical "bomb" dessert—a soft chocolate chip cookie paired ingeniously with ice cream. As one satisfied customer exclaimed, it's "appropriately named" for its explosive flavor! Another standout is the S'more tray, a fun and interactive dessert that enhances the cozy, backyard-like ambiance of Elli's. Ideal for family gatherings or a casual sweet escape, Elli's Backyard promises a top-tier dessert experience that tantalizes the taste buds and warms the heart.

A photo of Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel restaurant

8. Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel

4.4

Awesome(547)

Price: Moderate

• American • Red Bank

Booked 8 times today

If you're in search of quintessential comfort food, Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel in Red Bank is a culinary gem not to be missed. Known for its serene waterfront setting and contemporary American cuisine, Pearl delights diners with its use of local, seasonal ingredients that bring traditional comfort dishes to new heights. Reviewers consistently praise the quality and presentation of dishes like the "delicious" watermelon salad, lobster salad, and the red snapper for two, describing meals as "out of this world." The restaurant's ambiance, combined with attentive service, makes every meal memorable. One reviewer summed it up perfectly: "Incredible food and service. The oyster selection is second to none. A place to definitely try if you love seafood." With such high accolades, Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel stands out as a top choice for comfort food aficionados.

A photo of The Atlantic House restaurant

9. The Atlantic House

4.8

Exceptional(564)

Price: Expensive

• American • Atlantic Highlands

Booked 1 time today

At The Atlantic House in Atlantic Highlands, you're in for a treat with their standout Comfort Food offerings. Diners consistently rave about dishes like the "always spot on" Pot O' Clams and the double patty burger that's "absolutely delicious." One review highlighted, "The food was absolutely amazing. So much flavor in every bite." It's not just the food that gets high marks; the service is also a highlight, with mentions of attentive servers like Matt who make every visit special. Whether you're enjoying a casual dinner or a cozy drink, The Atlantic House delivers a perfect blend of quality, taste, and comfort in every dish.

10. McDonagh's Pub

4.2

Awesome(196)

Price: Moderate

• American • Keyport

Booked 5 times today

Nestled in the historic heart of Downtown Keyport, McDonagh's Pub offers a delightful take on Continental cuisine with a dash of local charm. Celebrated for its "phenomenal" dishes such as the McDonagh's Steak and a variety of thin-crust pizzas, the pub consistently garners praise for both its food and vibrant atmosphere. Guests rave about unique offerings like the Corned Beef Egg Rolls and Truffle Mac and Cheese, highlighting the quality and creativity of the menu. With its old-world ambiance complemented by modern culinary delights, McDonagh's provides an authentic Continental dining experience that locals and visitors alike adore. As one guest put it, the experience is simply "10/10" in every aspect, making it a must-visit destination in Keyport.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

A
Arman
New York City •10 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
We had a great time. Everything was great, had an awesome experience.
More info
The Robinson Ale House - Red BankPrice: Expensive• American• Red Bank
•
4.8
A
AnnaVIP
Atlantic City / South Jersey Shore •13 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Went there with 7 people on a Friday night. All of our drinks we had were so festive. The burnt tip appetizer was such a hit!! We also had the hummus, sweet potatoes and pretzels and they were also so delicious. Our waitress was wonderful! Highly recommend going here!
More info
Triumph Restaurant & BreweryPrice: Moderate• American• Red Bank
•
4.5
K
K.VIP
New York City •6 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
It’s literally impossible to have a bad dining experience at Semolina. The staff are phenomenal, the seasonally rotating menu is perfection, and the budino + espresso are a thing of beauty. The only thing that can go wrong when you visit Semolina is that you forget to BYOB. Plan ahead, pick your wine, and book a table now.
More info
Semolina RestaurantPrice: Expensive• Farm-to-table• Red Bank
•
4.8
M
Michele
New York City •7 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
We were looking for a great midway location and I was thrilled to find The GOAT! We could enjoy a fabulous meal and hear each other talk. 2 of our party are hearing challenged so this was very much appreciated. The bruschetta appetizer was perfect, house wine delicious and all our entree choices and dessert were fabulous.
More info
The Goat by David BurkePrice: Moderate• American• Union Beach
•
4.3
C
Carol
New York City •12 reviews
4.0
Dined on Nov 28, 2024
We went for Thanksgiving dinner. Disappointed that it was 'deli' turkey, and not carved off the bird. Also disappointed with the little dollop of whipped cream on the pumpkin pie. The sides were delicious, especially the mashed potatoes. I also enjoyed the seasonal drink - Midnight Harvest. Our server Matt was the best.
More info
Houlihan's - HolmdelPrice: Moderate• American• Holmdel
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Middletown

American

Best American Restaurants in Middletown

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

26 restaurants available nearby

1. Semolina Restaurant

2. Houlihan's - Holmdel

3. The Goat by David Burke

4. The Robinson Ale House - Red Bank

5. Triumph Restaurant & Brewery

6. The Dining Room - Molly Pitcher Inn

7. Elli’s Backyard

8. Pearl at The Oyster Point Hotel

9. The Atlantic House

10. McDonagh's Pub

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable