Best American Restaurants in Middletown

My birthday was on the 9th so we were using the birthday credit and also picking up some wine that was in my bullpen. The meal that I ordered was a Chef recommendation of the butternut squash and lobster and shrimp. The sauce was excellent and the meal was delicious. The sauce was so good that I asked for more of the bread to soak it all up and have that to finish off the meal. Then we each ordered a $4.99 truffle and those were a hit to send us home. Wow!!!

We had a wonderful dinner with great friends. We all ordered different items--steak, chicken parmesan, salmon, short ribs--all were delicious! Biscuits brought out first were fantastic--warm, moist & perfect with the butter. Portions are good-sized, and everything was as indicated on the menu. Server was attentive, and manager checked on us to make sure all was good. Nice & cozy environment decorated nicely with live entertainment. Was loud at first as other table had some boisterous folks, but it tapered down after they left. Don't think we've ever had a bad meal here. Will definitely be back.

Our server was very sweet and attentive. We've been twice for dinner in the past month (reservations prior to shows at the Sorg). The food is quite good... it's the time it takes to actually get to eat it. Once is an "oops", twice is the routine. VERY SLOW. Very good, but very slow both times. (and last night, there were only 2 people at the bar and empty tables on a Friday, so not sure why they wouldn't be right on it). Does have one good single malt scotch at the bar (Oban). The rest are just blends. Nice place, good food, directly across from the Sorg. But the kitchen is just so SLOW.

Food was great, service was great-Ben was our server and he did all he could to see that we had a good experience. Our food arrived quickly and was hot. We are wanting to go again soon and for Valentine’s Day 2025.

good time considering the circumstances. its a tradition!