Best American Restaurants in Big Pine Key

24 restaurants available nearby

1. La Te Da

4.7

Exceptional(2445)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 25 times today

Tropical open-air fine dining in a casual atmosphere. open seven days a week for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Reservations suggested. Classic elegant cuisine prepared in our unique style, featuring fresh local seafood and the finest cuts of meat. We offer an extensive wine list to satisfy all palates. Come experience a Key West tradition...La Te Da.

A photo of Four Marlins - The Reach Key West restaurant

2. Four Marlins - The Reach Key West

4.5

Awesome(854)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 18 times today

Four Marlins - The Reach Key West offers an exceptional American dining experience that captures the essence of coastal cuisine with its "fresh-caught fish" and "locally sourced ingredients." This standout restaurant is a contemporary nod to the tropical fishing lodges of the 1930s, providing diners with a truly authentic taste of America. Patrons rave about the "amazing Key Lime Pie," often hailed as the best in Key West, and the impeccable service that accompanies every meal. The Tide to Table dining experience, set against breathtaking ocean views, is a must-try for those seeking a memorable culinary adventure.

A photo of Milagro Restaurant and Bar restaurant

3. Milagro Restaurant and Bar

4.7

Exceptional(1050)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 12 times today

Milagro Restaurant and Bar in Key West offers an unparalleled Latin/Spanish culinary experience that is both authentic and exquisite. Nestled just blocks from the Southernmost Point, this hidden gem is celebrated for its "phenomenal" dishes and "outstanding" service. Run by the dynamic Montoya duo, Milagro masterfully crafts scratch-made, upscale fare with a focus on local seafood and wood-grilled specialties, promising a "delicious" and "memorable" dining adventure. Guests rave about the octopus appetizer and snapper entrée, calling them "top notch" and "delicious." With an inviting atmosphere and an extensive selection of wines and craft cocktails, Milagro is a must-visit destination for Latin/Spanish cuisine aficionados.

4. Ocean Grill & Bar

4.2

Awesome(1033)

Price: Moderate

• American • Key West

Booked 12 times today

Ocean Grill & Bar in Key West offers a "fantastic blend of American cuisine" with a seafood focus that truly sets it apart. Renowned for its inventive menu, the restaurant showcases dishes like 'Butter Poached Florida Lobster' and 'Shrimp & Grits', which have delighted diners and won awards. The chef's commitment to quality is evident in every bite, as patrons rave about the "exceptional service" and "consistently delicious food". Nestled on vibrant Duval Street, this spot is praised not only for its delectable offerings but also its warm, welcoming atmosphere, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic American flavors.

5. Bagatelle

4.6

Exceptional(4165)

Price: Moderate

• American • Key West

Booked 79 times today

Bagatelle, located in the heart of vibrant Key West, is a culinary gem that artfully blends American cuisine with local flavors. This charming restaurant is celebrated for its outstanding service and atmospheric dining experience, especially on the balcony overlooking the lively Duval Street. Guests rave about the "fantastic Eggs Benedict" and "incredible swordfish," highlighting its commitment to quality and authenticity. The chefs at Bagatelle expertly craft imaginative seafood dishes that consistently impress, making it a must-visit for those seeking an exceptional American dining experience. Whether you're indulging in their "killer Crunchy French Toast" or catching the sunset with a tropical cocktail, Bagatelle promises a memorable meal.

A photo of Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset Key restaurant

6. Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset Key

4.8

Exceptional(15564)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 167 times today

Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset Key offers an unforgettable Seafood dining experience that stands out for its quality and authenticity. Nestled on a private island, this restaurant is renowned for its "absolutely delicious" dishes, such as the fresh snapper and the "best Lobster Bisque" that leaves a lasting impression. Diners rave about the "superb food" and "outstanding service," with the ocean views providing a stunning backdrop to the meal. The seared grouper and yellowtail snapper have been described as "awesome," making Latitudes a must-visit for seafood aficionados seeking a perfect blend of flavor, ambiance, and exceptional service.

7. Nine One Five

4.7

Exceptional(4066)

Price: Moderate

• American • Key West

Booked 60 times today

Nestled in a charming Victorian house in Key West, Nine One Five offers a delightful journey through Contemporary European cuisine that is nothing short of spectacular. Highly praised by diners, the restaurant creates a “wonderful culinary experience” with its fresh, beautifully presented dishes. Among the standout favorites are the She-Crab Ravioli and the bacon-wrapped dates, which are “to die for.” The impeccable service and cozy ambiance make it perfect for any occasion. With its eclectic menu, which includes homemade pasta dishes and a superb wine list, Nine One Five is a must-visit for those seeking an authentic taste of Europe.

8. A&B Lobster House

4.7

Exceptional(4845)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 53 times today

A&B Lobster House in Key West is a true gem of authentic American cuisine, where the freshest seafood meets expertly crafted steaks. Diners rave about the "unbelievable food" and "amazing service," with standout dishes like the Wagyu ribeye and lobster tail leaving a lasting impression. The restaurant's surf and turf options are described as "the best in the keys," making it a must-visit for those seeking a quintessential American dining experience. Set against the backdrop of a charming marina view, A&B Lobster House offers not just a meal, but a memorable culinary journey marked by quality and tradition.

A photo of Red Shoe Island Bistro restaurant

9. Red Shoe Island Bistro

5.0

Exceptional(1299)

Price: Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 35 times today

Red Shoe Island Bistro in Key West is a seafood lover's paradise, renowned for its fresh and authentic offerings. Nestled in the heart of old town on Petronia, this charming bistro serves up exquisite dishes like yellowtail snapper and Key West pink shrimp, ensuring every bite is "to die for" with flavors that are "incredibly balanced." The limited menu is a testament to their commitment to freshness, with each dish prepared to perfection. "The food is phenomenal," and the service "exceptional," making it a must-visit destination. With an inviting ambiance and standout dishes, Red Shoe Island Bistro is a seafood gem not to be missed.

10. Cafe Marquesa

4.8

Exceptional(2975)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Key West

Booked 30 times today

Cafe Marquesa in Key West is a shining beacon of authentic American cuisine, masterfully blending the island's rich culinary heritage with a fresh, coastal twist. As a premier choice for fine dining, its menu is a harmonious blend of the finest seafood, meats, and produce, celebrated in dishes that delight and surprise. "Unbelievable and delicious," one diner raves, capturing the essence of the experience. The attentive service and elegant ambiance enhance the dining journey, making every visit a memorable occasion. Relish in the genuine flavors and creativity that make Cafe Marquesa a must-visit destination for American cuisine enthusiasts.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

J
JimVIP
London •15 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Food was excellent as was the service. Daniel our server was very helpful in explaining the various food options and was always checking in on us to be sure everything was ok.
More info
Four Marlins - The Reach Key WestPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Key West
•
4.5
K
KateVIP
Las Vegas •66 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Very cute restaurant right in the heart of Key West. The server was attentive. The food was very good. We had lobster pasta, seared tuna, and burrata salad as appetizer. Highly recommend to try this place if you in Keys.
More info
BagatellePrice: Moderate• Seafood• Key West
•
4.6
D
DomVIP
Greater Boston •10 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Great ambience, very good service and most of all, delicious dishes. My snapper was silky , mild, and delicious and my partner’s duck was amazing. And we stayed for the show afterwards!
More info
La Te DaPrice: Expensive• American• Key West
•
4.7
C
Caitlin
Washington, D.C. Area •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 5 days ago
Every item each of us ordered was outstanding! I would highly recommend.
More info
Ocean Grill & BarPrice: Moderate• Seafood• Key West
•
4.2
C
Carla
New York City •24 reviews
4.0
Dined 5 days ago
Really great service. Good food. Lively place. You can eat at the bar.
More info
Milagro Restaurant and BarPrice: Expensive• American• Key West
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Big Pine Key

American

Best American Restaurants in Big Pine Key

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

24 restaurants available nearby

1. La Te Da

2. Four Marlins - The Reach Key West

3. Milagro Restaurant and Bar

4. Ocean Grill & Bar

5. Bagatelle

6. Latitudes Key West, FL on Sunset Key

7. Nine One Five

8. A&B Lobster House

9. Red Shoe Island Bistro

10. Cafe Marquesa

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable