Best American Restaurants in Caledonia

The shrimp and grits were amazing but the steak with the surf and turf was not very good. The Mississippi mud pie was amazing as well

We had a perfect experience on Valentine’s Day! Our reservation was at 5:00 pm and we were seated promptly. Our server was polite and quick. Our steaks were cooked perfectly and our kids enjoyed their meals. The s’more dessert was top notch! We bought a bottle of wine to take home for the evening. Thank you for another great experience at this location!

This was our first visit to The Post Tavern inside the Ada Hotel. I am not easily impressed, but I thoroughly enjoyed our experience. The space itself has a lot of natural light shining in, which balances some of the dark, modern interior finishings very well. The service was amazing, and the food was top notch. My partner had the Shepherd’s Pie, and I had the Lobster Mac. Both were delicious and of high quality. The plating of the Shepherd’s Pie was especially beautiful, and I was very pleased with the amount of lobster in the Mac. Highly recommend visiting The Post Tavern!

Dan is an awesome service provider. Helpful, pleasant, knowledgeable and very helpful. Enjoyed our interaction. Had the Seabass and Filet- both dinners outstanding. We should have signed up for the frequent customer program as we will be back!

We always have the best dining experience. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about the menu and specials. The cocktails are creative and the wine selection is fantastic. It is a great experience, highly recommend this restaurant.